Reviews for Salvatore's Tomato Pies in Sun Prairie, WI
Stopped for dinner while in the area and had a great experience! Buffalo wings were excellent. We got a classic tomato pie and a... Fat Uncle Tony's. Pizza was great and came out quick. Everything was very fresh. I like that they have several non-alcoholiccocktails on their menu. Would definitely come back again! Read more
Great food! We had the classic pizza and it was so tasty plus the crust was perfect. Also had the meatball appetizer and that... was very flavorful as well. The restaurant also got a good look to it. Kid friendly with high chairs. Good prices too! Read more
Visited Salvatore's for dinner with my daughter. Very cool restaurant and atmosphere. Service was great - attentive and... polite. We had the truffle fries and a large Fat Uncle Tony pizza. The fries were amazing...my daughter said they are her newfavorite and would stop again for the fries alone. The pizza was equally fantastic. We ended up bringing half the pizza backhome with us. However, the coolest thing might have been the robot that delivered pizzas and salads from the back of therestaurant to the front for carryout. It was so cool. It also looks like their carryout business was quite busy...which I wouldconsider carryout in the future, but the atmosphere inside is certainly worth going inside to sit down. Great place. Will visitagain and again! Read more
Went at lunch on a Friday. Our waitress was very attentive and kind. The food was pretty good. We had the wings and the sausage... pepperoni pizza. The wings were good, but nothing out of the ordinary. The pizza had really good texture. Thin with a reallynice crunch and softness at the same time. The overall flavor of the pizza was also pretty good. I wouldn't say the best pizzaI have ever had, but I enjoyed the food and would go back. Read more
I really like their pizza, but we make our pie and it seems they always skip one or two ingredients that we pay extra for. This... time I had enough. I am Looking for the spinach edit: 5 spinach leaves do not cost $2 and condescending responses means one lesscustomer. Disappointed at the lack of customer service and poor taste dealing with criticism. Also insinuating there was nocontact when in fact several emails were sent before the review was posted. Read more
Truly great pizza pies! It's obvious that Salvatore's takes pride in their craft. I was pleased to see that they use fresh... ingredients that are locally sourced. This was my first time here and I got the monthly special pie "Third Street and Main." Iwill definitely be back while I am still in the area for work. Read more
Great food & great service. Everyone was very attentive and on top of it. As a culinary professional myself I noticed a lot of... things they did very well. First the ambiance is fun and eclectic. Second the staff aware and working well as a team, third themenu was a lot of fun and so many great ideas and options. Finally the execution was perfect and timely. We will be back. Read more
There were 6 people in our group. The small pizzas were delicious.. crispy crust. I ordered a cheeseburger and fries. The... meat was so fresh and delicious. I only did 4 stars because they should offer pasta as a side dish. Pasta made inhouse...sounds delicious! Place is clean, staff friendly. Read more