Reviews for Vintage Italian Pizza in Superior, WI

Marilyn Anderson 1 year ago

Got there a little before 5 pm on a Thursday. There were only two other people in the restaurant, so they definitely weren?t... busy. We didn?t get our pizza until 5:55pm. Waitress couldn?t even be bothered to come give us an update or refill our waters.When we finally got our pizza, my order was wrong. Waitress just said she?ll ?tell them in the back.? That doesn?t fix my pizzaor give me back my wasted time at this place. Pizza was mediocre, at best. Wouldn?t come back. Read more

KRIS'TE 1 year ago

The best pizza ive had in years. We even took some sauce home with us . Waitress seemed a bit annoyed with our questions as we... had never been there before. Maybe if she wasnt she would have gotten a bigger tip reguardless of it being the end of thenight. we were impressed with the food would totally go back again. Read more

Joan Bethke 1 year ago

Reasonable and delicious food. Found out the two locations in Duluth only have pizza and calzones. The restaurant in Superior... has a large menu and nice atmosphere. I miss all the high-heel shoes hung on the wall in the women's room. Apparently, too manyshoes were taken. How sad. Read more

Roy Hanley 1 year ago

The pizza from here is great. Sat in the bar and waited for take out with my 3 year old. She got a free lemonade. There is also... a dinning area. Clean. Friendly staff. Read more

Nilesh Naik 1 year ago

This place has a decent pizza and the server was great. The restaurant has a nice country vibe and the beer selection is also... diverse as well as country oriented. Definitely worth trying if you are in the neighborhood. Read more

Chris Childers 2 years ago

The décor was cozy and welcoming . The wait staff was very nice and accommodating. However, I can?t overlook the fact that... the kitchen staff was engaged in a very loud discussion about having diarrhea. This was a deal-breaker for me. The flatbreadappetizer (normally a very quick to prepare item), took a long time to come out and was overloaded with toppings - so much thatsome portions were very cold and did not get cooked all the way through. I wanted to love this place but so many bad thingshappened! Read more

Phil Franke 2 years ago

Amazing pizza. Good food means you may have to wait as it's busy but it's worth it!

Jon Reimer 2 years ago

Love this place! A large menu full of tasty treats! For thin crust, classic pizza, this is the best place in the Twin Ports. But... when you add in the calories, desserts and the great beer selection this becomes an easy 5-star rated restaurant for me! Read more