Reviews for EARLY AMERICAN TAVERN in Sussex, NJ
Fun night out. Large tables so tables of 6 are easy to seat. The service and food were good. Always a festive atmosphere. The... sweet potato fries are super yum and I really enjoyed the prime rib sandwich. Read more
Once again, always impressive. The cosmo that the bartender Brian made me was fantastic. The manager Tammy made us feel right at... home. And the rest of the staff was hustling around. The food came out in a timely matter. And was outstanding. Will always keepcoming back. Read more
Tonight I ordered the meatloaf with mashed potatoes no gravy with butter. Received something that looked like a dismantled... meatball with mashed potatoes and gravy. Definitely not what I was expecting, wish I would have received meatloaf. Well I didn?teat it, not even a bite. They dropped the bill from $16 to $8, that was generous but I still paid $8 for a meal that wasn?tmeatloaf. I will not be returning. Read more
This afternoon we celebrated my daughters new job at Disney World at the Early American Tavern. They have a great space upstairs... that accommodated all of my guests. Tammy worked with me through the whole experience. She is so responsive to emails, flexibleand accommodating with my requests! She even allowed me to come in yesterday to see the room set up! She made the day so easyon me, I could enjoy all of my guests!! I highly recommend Early American Tavern for your next party! Read more
Early American Tavern has earned my personal ?Best BLT? award. My sister loved her pizza, my mother loved the French onion soup.... Everything was great about this place, especially the fact that the entertainment (a band at the time I was there) wasn?t at alloverpowering. I do recommend it! Read more
Went tonight for our second time because we received an offer for BOGO wings. The first time we had entrees that were really... good so we wanted to go back to try some pub food. The wings were excellent!!! So BIG, crispy, and the flavor of the teriyakiand garlic parm was great. Our server and everyone was so friendly. Can't wait to go back and try more things. Nice relaxedrustic atmosphere. Read more
As I entered the Early American Tavern, I thought it was going to be a delightful experience. The rustic look brought joy to me... and my fellow friends. We were seated and greeted by our waitress. She took our order and was back with solo cups as our drinks.Our drinks were served at 8:25 and waited for our food for over an hour. The waitress came back only once after we asked forher. After our food was served we had a burger that was very unpleasant and the food was not the wait. As a hungry customer Ithought this experience was not delightful. Read more
Great place! Love the atmosphere! Food was really good and the people working were super friendly and fun. Definitely a place to... visit if you're in the area. Read more