Reviews for Papa Murphy's | Take 'N' Bake Pizza in Sussex, WI

Constantly closing due to staff shortages but continues to take online orders, so you show up expecting pizza only to find a... locked door. Read more

Papa Murphy?s is my absolute favorite place to go for pizza! The staff here is always nice and efficient and the food is... delicious. I would definitely recommend going here! Read more

Staff is great, but management is poor. had to return 2 pizzas Saturday 1/22/22 that were poorly made. Decided against having... them remade as the manager had a poor attitude. They said they would process a refund for the returned pizzas but as of 10 dayslater still hasn't happened. Temporarily closed now?? Read more

Came in 12/22 at 6:45 to place an order, first I was told there were no family size pizzas, so I ordered a large. Cashier was... rude and acted inconvenienced that I was there ordering. While the pizza was being made the two males behind the counter wentback and forth about how they shouldn't have to be making my pizza and that "they want to kill themselves" because I didn'tplace an online order. Then they talked about closing and locking the door early as soon as I left. What a joke. The female thatgave me the pizza when it was done was nice and courteous atleast. Read more

Ordered a $10 Tuesday night pizza with sausage, mushrooms, black olives and sundried tomato. Husband didn't check when he left... and got home with no black olives or mushrooms! Receipt was correct (Name on receipt is Ray), but prepared incorrectly. Verydisappointing. I understand that they where busy but better care in verifying order would be appreciated. Tried to call andcomplain but phone message said that they couldn't take calls at that time?!?!? no option to leave a voice message??? Read more

They do a great job, filled our order quickly. Not happy with the crust options however. They said we were limited to the thin... crust on the large (pretty sure it was the large.. One of the sizes). We would have preferred the thicker crust. Either way itwas delicious. Our group liked the Cowboy over the veggie. Read more

Prompt and friendly service with a clean environment. The staff seems genuinely happy to be there and is always ready to answer... any questions. There are lots of options to choose from. Online ordering is also very convenient. I would definitely recommendthis pizza place. Read more

The food really is not great. For the price I would rather go to the frozen food section. I have tried their pizza on several... occasions and always have come to the same conclusion. The crust doesn't seem to rise enough to be considered a hand tossed. Thetoppings are not in large enough portions to make the pizza Good. The location is clean and the workers are nice. However,neither matter because their food is simply not good. Read more