Reviews for Johnny's New York Style Pizza in Suwanee, GA

We moved to the Atlanta area from New York in 2018 and could not find a good Italian restaurant until we tried Johnny's. Don't... get me wrong, I still miss Ray's Famous pizza in the West Village but Johnny's is a close second. Read more

I ordered a 'supreme' pizza, medium. The green peppers were so tiny, I couldn't taste them. The mushrooms were almost... non-existent, and it had too much sausage and pepperoni!! I didn't taste or see any evidence of cheese, or tomato sauce!?@# Itwas very nasty. The 'Arnold Palmer' tea I got tasted like dish water or worse!! It was thoroughly disgusting, and they had thenerve to charge $23.00 for that garbage! I'm a native New Yorker, so I know how pizza should taste. Also, the seats weredirty, and the mexican chef kept coughing and sneezing, while cooking, with no mask on!!! A terrible experience, and a bigwaste of money. I like Puzza Hut the best. Read more

Good atmosphere, the attention is excellent and the staff is always with a smile to assist you! The best of Suwanee

Best pizza joint in the county. Once ownership changed to Patrick it got even better. Come get a beer, watch sports, and eat.

Our favorite place to eat our favorite pizza! Salads are fresh and good amount of it. I like that the dressing is on side so I... can control the taste. Pizza is great! Great taste of dough and not too much of sauce. My favorite is a traditional Strombolibut one thing that I don?t like is a little of raw dough inside of the ends. Today pizza was too salty, don?t now why. Very nicewaiter! Read more

Cool..i'm the 200th reviewer of this location. I cannot say enough good things about this place. I have not eaten at all... locations only this one. They sling dough like no other.. seriously the pizza is killer! You have to try their Hawaiian withgarlic butter on the crust and a little on the side. It must be the ham they use. I normally do not like Hawaiian whatsoever.The staff are always friendly, accommodating and fast. Read more

Burnt pizza delivered cold one and a half hours after I ordered it. Looks like the delivery guy got too hungry on his journey... and had to pull off and eat a piece of the topping. The white you see is a exposed dough. I definitely will not be orderingfrom here again! Read more

Really good food, good sized portions, a lot of items on the menu, great service and reasonable prices. The dining area is... pretty small but it has a cool ambiance. There's also outdoor seating. Read more