Reviews for Eddie's in Sylvan Beach, NY
Excellent service. The Manhattan Clam Chowder was loaded and very delicious. I got the Italian Sampler (manicotti, 1/2... eggplant parm, and 1/2 lasagna. Everything was homemade and the sauce was fantastic. My wife had the roast pork. It was some ofthe most flavourful roast pork I've had in years. Great service, great food, and fair prices. Will definitely be back. Read more
Some of the food was okay and other meals were just bad. No one in my party really enjoyed their meal. The service was pretty... good and our waitress was very nice. Overall if it were not for the food this would have been a good dinner, but the food wasvery disappointing. Read more
Wonderful friendly staff. Food is amazing here! Nice place to bring the whole family of all ages! Highly recommended!
We love this restaurant. We had a family group of 24 people from all over the country. Our server was friendly & attentive. She... got all of our food & drink orders correct. There was an excellent variety of choices on the menu to please everyone, but themajority of us got the fish fry. The food came out in a timely fashion. Be forewarned, the bowls of clam chowder are HUGE. Wewill be back whenever we're in town. Read more
We love Eddie's. It's our anniversary go-to for prime rib and great service with a smile! Highly recommend!
Following my blood drive appointment in Cleveland, N.Y., I visited Eddie's on March 29th. Greeted with the general layout of a... 50's diner and Elvis music, I thought this was going to be quite the experience. I was right. The homemade chips were addictive,the burger was properly cooked and expertly seasoned. The server was very attentive. All in all, a terrific time was had. Ifyou're visiting Sylvan Beach, give Eddie's a visit. Read more
Place is stuck in a time warp but overall not bad. It is overpriced for what you get. $18 fish fry. Service was good and... friendly. 50 cents for a refill? 3.00 for the initial Coke? Cmon. The portions were also small along with processed deliham on the grilled cheese. Read more
Tried their famous Hot Ham Sandwich aaaand it was spicy. Wish they could give you a choice to change your side vs ordering an... extra side (paying full price for it) and not getting the one it comes originally with. But the sandwich was good. The Italiangreens were very good as well. Read more