Reviews for Harpoon Eddie's in Sylvan Beach, NY
Very fun atmosphere and nice scenery. Boom Boom shrimp ???? tacos ???? were delicious ????
We had a really good time, good haddock dinner our server was awesome, the band was great to , the Beadle Brothers, we'll be... back Read more
We were sat very quickly. The restaurant wasn't very busy and they had plenty of Staff. Took quite some time to get our drinks,... then we specifically asked the waitress if they has iceberg Lettuce for our son she went to ask the kitchen they said yes. Weordered and it took an hour to get our food. The waitress claimed there was an issue in the kitchen and some tickets didn't getprinted, however 3 other tables that came in after us were served. The food, they had no iceberg, the pulled pork and lobstermac & cheese were good, not worth almost $25 a plate, they have no lids for kid drinks, the kids grilled cheese was awful! Allyou could taste was oily butter like flavor. Burgers were average, fries were good. Although its ridiculous when you ask forfries instead of house chips and have to pay $8 for the fry appetizer. House chips would be better if they were seasoned! Theladies room is clean and the decor was a cute touch. The atmosphere and view of the water was also nice. Service sucked. Likeone of the top 5 worse ever!!! Not worth the money. Read more
Food was overpriced and not good, service was very bad. Barely saw the waitress, had to chase her down to pay the bill, never... got refills on water etc. I'm sure she was nice, but I'm assuming it's a management issue with training and assigning too manytables . Mahi was bland, walnuts on the salad were burnt, everything lacked flavor. Would not recommend. Read more
My black and blue burger was amazing. Other food was pretty good. Service was very poor. We never got silverware or napkins,... some workers are very busy and obviously having trouble keeping track of things. Meanwhile one worker just walked around talkingto people and not helping anyone the entire time we were there. Outside is nice but the tables are shiny metal and burned yourskin. We had to move inside. If it's not packed, I would still recommend stopping in for the food. Parking is also brutal duringpeak season. Read more
This is our go to place in SB when we are out on the motorcycle. Love the outside seating / bar area. Great view of the beach,... and they often have live music during the day which we also love. Service is great even when they are jam packed ( their staffhustles !!! ) parking can be tricky bikes up front normally , a car may have to park and walk a little bit. Prices and food aregood. Read more
This is one of those classic restaurants on the water with live music. It has awesome views of the beach and sunset! The bands... are usually the better ones in the area too. However like in most of the atmospheric restaurants the food sucks. Our partyordered a couple burgers that looked like hockey pucks and were just as hard. The pizza looks like totinos frozen, the waitresswas rude and they only had three servers on all night for about 25 tables which is absurd. Your paying for the view not thequality of food or drinks . Read more
We parked on the street and entered the main door. We were immediately greeted and sat outside (our preference). The band was... just about to start. The place wasnt packed, and people were spread out. Our server took our drink order, but it took quite awhile for her to return. The outdoor bar had a few people at it, but they seemed understaffed as far as servers. We orderedClams & Sausage as an appetizer. It was amazing. Our meals came shortly after. We had Lobster Mac n Cheese and a Shrimp Po BoySand. We enjoyed our food while listening to the band and enjoying the atmosphere being right next to beach. The food wasamazing, great atmosphere, just service was slow to get additional drinks and our check. Read more