Reviews for Brooklyn Pickle East in Syracuse, NY
Loved this place. They don?t overload the meat so the sandwich is not falling all over the place. The mixed Italian on... everything bread is shown below. Bonus points for the interior which is straight out of the 90's. I will return. Read more
This was my first time visiting The Brooklyn Pickle, as well as the city of Syracuse. I had the Brooklyn Pickle Special half... sub, and it was delicious! I highly recommend it. I would have taken a picture to show others how much food you get (bigportions, but nothing ridiculous), but I was so hungry, I ate it up lol I also got some garlic pickles. They were tender andalso delicious. Read more
A well oiled machine designed to service regulars. Excellent quality ingredients, and for the most part, assembled pretty well.... Had their take on a reuben/pastrami and a tuna fish on wheat. Tuna Fish was fresh but lacked any seasoning whatsoever. I'd addsome sort of vinegar-y condiment to liven it up. The Brooklyn special had perfectly cooked and sliced pastrami. Seasoned well,it could have had a touch more of the sauce or added some mustard to round it out. Would return. Read more
Everything's perfect except for the only weird thing is every time in the past 20 years I've gone to this exact location there... has always been a sense of happiness and talking/ joking amongst each so each other. Not the case this visit, not even anysmiles. Sandwiches are always way too big to finish absolutely amazing fresh meat and perfect soups they make them homemadeevery single day and it's just great Read more
I've always loved Brooklyn Pickle but after all these years, I finally tried the Neptune Stew. Amazing! If you've been, you... already know the sandwiches are great, they weigh the meat to make sure your sandwiches are monsterous. Read more
You really can't go wrong here. It's a good sandwich with better quality ingredients than sandwich/sub chains. The service is... pretty quick as they have multiple order takers at different stations. They have a variety of other items and an extensivebeverage selection. What makes them unique is that they don't skimp on their meat portions. It's no Carnegie deli portion butit is a very fair amount. The sandwich makers never touch the money. They yell out the order to the money handler and theycome to you to take payment. They are efficient and delicious. Read more
I usually go to the Brooklyn pickle west, but I was over in that direction so I stopped at the one on Burnet Avenue. Super... disappointed at the quality of food I received after paying almost $30 for two sandwiches. The one worker making the sandwichesfailed to put the correct type of tomato, wrong bread, and the wrong meat that I asked for. One of the sandwiches was wrappedOK, but the other as you can see in the picture, looks absolutely terrible. The bag was in a horizontal position with thesandwich exposed and now there are pieces of the sandwich on the floor of my car. The other workers were just standing aroundand watching, not helping. Not happy at all, I usually brush off bad experiences but this has got to be better. PERIOD. Not tomention the guy sneezed twice and was wearing his mask below his nose. Read more
This place has a nice atmosphere, I enjoyed the vibe in here. I got a ham salad sub that was really tasty! Not many places offer... ham salad so I was delighted to see it on the menu. My sub was made really quickly and with a drink and a side it was around$12. Not bad for a full meal! Great quick place to grab a bite with friends. Read more