Reviews for Coleman's Authentic Irish Pub in Syracuse, NY
Brought 2 friends with me last night. One friend and I Ordered scallop dinner. I know seafood is expensive but... Received 4... scallops..ok. ordered twice baked potato. It was the size of HALF A SALT POTATO,! Cole Slaw in very tiny cup. Come onguys!!! The music was so loud waitress turned down; but, it was turned back up. We couldn't hear each other. (Other friendordered Shepard's Pie-wonderful.) Read more
The food is always amazing and the atmosphere is awesome! But what's even better is when they help you find a phone that... accidently got knocked off the bar into the trash. In fact, it was found inside the dumpster! Thank you to the staff atColeman's and especially Reggie who was relentless and on a mission to find the phone! We appreciate you! Kudos to Coleman's!From... a Coleman descendent! If I could give 10 stars I would! Read more
One of the most essential places in Syracuse. A great dinner and an even better night out! The food is outstanding,... particularly the Shepherds Pie and Bangers and Mash. Excellent staff, great draft beers and the atmosphere is ?quintessentiallySyracuse?. I lived on Tipp Hill for a while, and always make it a point to return when I visit home. Come by for a pint, ameal and a laugh - it?ll be grand! Read more
Coleman's is an amazing Irish pub with excellent food, drinks and service, we have been going there for decades. Keep a look out... for a leprechaun, he has his own phone booth, door as well as a bench! Read more
Great place to go if you want to hang out with drunk underage kids! The great food and Irish pub vibe is ruined by college slobs... a lot of the time. Green beer is cool tho and I liked the green cider this year, I hope this comes back. Shepards pie here is10/10. Bar tenders handle busy time well. Good service Read more
I went for a late lunch, love the interior, ordered fish and chips, the fish was ok, no seasoning whatsoever, the fish was not... crispy it was soggy to say the least. It came with coleslaw. the coleslaw came in a condiment cup , I give you props on thechips, I ordered ice tea which wasn't very good. There was a odor when you walked in. The place could use a detail cleaning, thebottom of the table was grimy and let's not talk about the floor that could use a detail scrubbing. I was not impressed whatsoever, I was very disappointed . Read more
I love this place! We had reservations for a party of 12 and they had no problems accommodating us. $4 1/2 &1/2 special that... night until 7:00 you can?t go wrong there. They also had 1911 Honey Crisp on tap. If you like the Honey Crisp then you know howhard it is to find right now. I had the Guinness Steak Burger. It?s a delicious burger on a potato pancake topped with Welchcheese and onion rings. No bun it?s a knife and fork burger. Freaking amazing! Stop in the gift shop they have great t-shirts! Read more
I have been here many times. The first time I was in I was attending a wedding that was hosted up stairs. The food was very good... and service was excellent. The feel of the place adds charm and the drinks come out right. Beer selection is good andoccasionally new things are offered. They do a lot community involvement and have activities frequently. Best thing on the menuis their steak with the Irish fries! Bathrooms are spotless. If you are in the area stop by you won't regret it! Read more