Reviews for Scotch' N Sirloin in Syracuse, NY
For the last 15 years our group has a Holiday meal here. Very nice a before dinner drink at the fireplace. Then dinner every... year been top notch. Last year service and prime rib not so. Checked resent review I guess we need to find some other place.Suspect this will be another failed restaurant. Too bad Read more
The service staff was fantastic and very attentive. I appreciate that a bunch!!! However, I've been here multiple times and... each visit my filet has been grossly under cooked. It's somewhat disappointing as this purposeful "hole in the wall" looks likea gem, but isn't. Read more
Our servers were TOP NOTCH! We split the chopped salad for our appetizer ( which is meal in itself) and thoroughly enjoyed every... bite! My Delmonico was tender and prepared to perfection. My wife's sirloin steak was delicious. Read more
High end steak house with a somewhat limited menu. We sat inside in the dining room, but they offered outdoor seating along... with a lounge option. Very extensive liquor menu. Although we were there to celebrate Lisa's birthday, neither of us sampledthe liquor. When I made the reservation the gentleman asked if we were celebrating anything, and I told him. The picture onthis review is of the lovely dessert they brought us. It looks like a flower. It was vanilla and mint chocolate chip icecreams with whipped cream, and delicious. We both had beef options - the sirloin for me, and the filet for her. Both wereperfectly cooked and drained just right. Lisa reports that the mashed potatoes that accompanied her dish were the best she'sever had, and I had to agree. I chose the steak fries, which were wedges, and also fantastic. To start we had the French onionsoup, also delicious - not too salty with just the right amount of onions. In a romantic twist, we went there 19 years ago forour first date. Highly recommend. Dinner for two, with soup but no drinks was a little more than $100, but worth every penny. Read more
Thanks to Covid it had been a long time since my husband and I had a date night, so I was excited to learn that he had made a... reservation for us at Scotch 'N Sirloin since we have had a number of enjoyable experiences there in the past. Things startedoff good - we were seated promptly and staff was friendly (albeit a bit inexperienced). I was disappointed that the salad barwas no longer, but figured that due to the pandemic they would probably just include a premade salad with the meal. They didn't.Our steaks were cooked well and tasted great, but I can't believe that for the price we paid all we got was a steak and 1 side!We ordered dessert, and my husband's pecan pie was delicious. My lemon tart however tasted like fish! When the waitress cameover to check on us, she left the check and asked if we wanted to box the dessert. When we told her about the problem with thedessert, she apologized and took it away with no offer to bring another or to adjust the check. This outing that was meant to bea special treat turned into a big disappointment. We could have gone to one of the national chains, had better food and service,and paid 1/3 of the price. :( Read more
The food was excellent. The service could have been better. The team of servers seemed very bothered when asked questions and... during a conversation at my table (that sat 8 of us) a male server was listening in and was rolling his eyes while makingdespicable facial expressions. As soon as he saw that 2 of us noticed it he did not come back to our table. The bus boy at thesalad bar was so helpful and pleasantly polite. I would definitely come back for the food. I just hope the attitude of theservers changes. And they use their manners while reaching over my plate to get my empty glass Update: WONDERFUL! SERVERS WEREAWESOME!!! DESSERT (CHOCOLATE PB PIE) WAS GREAT!!! Read more
My husband and I went here for our first anniversary, and it was lovely! My husband got the teriyaki steak (delicious!) with... sweet potato fries (done to perfection!) and chocolate peanut butter pie for dessert (so peanut buttery!). I got the linguiniprimavera (so flavorful!) and the creme brulee for dessert (ahh SO good!). The lighting was somewhat on the dark side, but ourtable was lit by its own overhead lamp, as many of the tables are, which was very helpful. I, for one, enjoyed the moodlighting. We let them know it was our anniversary ahead of time and they gave us a sweet little dessert with candles on it andthe words ?happy anniversary?, which was so nice! The staff were very pleasant and extremely helpful, especially with all thequestions and requests we had! ???? I would definitely recommend this restaurant! Read more
I'm being nice w 2 stars cuz the cuts of meat r good, too bad they ruined them. Meat overcooked, no seasoning and I'm mean not... even a pinch of salt. The shrimp , absolutely flavorless , no seasoning , salt or anything. I used to come here quite oftenabout 15 yrs ago. I will never be back , what a waste of $150. Waitress never returned , was never asked if I needed a refillfor my drink and my silverware was filthy , I mean what the hell happened to this place, it's truly sad Read more