Reviews for Crusty's Pizza in Tamarack, ID
Customer service was awful, lady at the counter was more interested in macking on her girlfriend than even attempting to smile... to any of the customers. Will not be visiting again, the pizza place in town has better pizza anyways. Read more
Has to be one of the worst most overpriced pizza I've ever had. I bought 1 slice, an order of cheesy garlic bread and a drink... cost over 20 bucks. Was told some pizza was from day before just needs to be warmed up. If I wanted pepperoni. Pizza was blandand not very good. Garlic bread was decent, but hard to mess up something when you slather butter and cheese on it. To eachtheir own, but not for me. Read more
Whoever was working today 8/15/22 at noon. I have never been treated so poorly. I brought my employee and I in for pizza and he... blatantly ignored us in line and called a women behind us up, took her order then yelled at us that the pizza wouldn?t be readyfor 45 minutes before even stating what we wanted. I don?t understand why it?s so hard to show common decency in a work place.We walked out and will not be going back. We live here full time, always tip well, and treat others well. Sorry you lost ourbusiness ??????????? Read more
This certainly is not the quality of Crusty's in McCall, even though they are apparently the same owner. Pizza crust was thin,... undercooked and flavorless. Then was charged $2.77 for a water cup. Every eating experience at Tamarack so far has been anegative one. Read more
Employees were friendly and nice. Pizza was $10 a slice or 9.99 if you want to be specific. Beer was less than a slice of pizza... and I would have almost saved money buying a whole pizza. I would not eat here again as the slices are so thin and we?re notcompletely cooked even after reheating, it was still kinda doughy. At ten bucks a slice I should be satisfied and not need tobuy 2 both slices being doughy. The facilities are beautiful and well maintained but I would much rather have the older resortsetup if food is sub par and three times the expense with new buildings. Read more
Took a gamble on this place since the reviews were so split. I don't understand the Italy comments because I have also been... there several times and this pizza is absolutely nowhere near the quality. I would say it's below Domino's or Pizza Hut inflavor, at least the formaggio w/ pepperoni is. I agree that crust is good though. It's open late and the workers were nice andhelpful, but I wouldn't go here again. Read more
Amazing crust. I would put it up against some of the Tuscan crusts I have tasted in Italy. The owner is amazing. Works hard for... his employees and customers. Great pizza, we are lucky to have them in the community. Read more
We were fortunate enough to get Crusty?s Pizza at Tamarack to cater our pre-wedding event. Brian from Crusty?s was extremely... accommodating to our requests for the evening event with approximately 70 people. The service was great and everyone enjoyed thepizza, salad and beer! Would highly recommend for an event or just a family dinner after a day of skiing or enjoying theTamarack Resort. Read more