Reviews for New York New York Pizza in Tampa, FL
Tried this pizza for the first time tonight and it was delicious. After my first bite I immediately yelled ?best pizza ever?.... I?ve never had New York pizza in NY but I was told by my husband who is from NY it is the closets I could have. I loved it.Staff super nice (which is always a plus). Recommend without reservations. Tania Roman Read more
Ordered white pizza for my birthday after reading wonderful reviews. Terrible! Burnt, slightly black crust, sparse mozzarella... cheese all dried up, not plump, or gooey, looked and tasted like days old cheese. NO GARLIC! Garlic and the ricotta cheese iswhat makes a white pizza! Ricotta cheese was okay. Again, all around the ricotta cheese was hard and dried up. . .supposed to bewet, with buttery garlic taste. Was a Friday night at 8 p.m. No one dining in and you burned the pizza? Ate one slice, taking itback tomorrow to get my $20 back. Read more
Ordered on UberEats - came here to review because the pizza was so unreasonably delicious! Best pizza I?ve had in Tampa - and I... eat too much pizza. Where has this pizza been my whole life?! Will definitely be ordering again. Pizza has a great NY thincrust, and a crispy, light and airy crust edge. The pizza sauce must be house made - it is clearly made with fresh tomato andgarlic. Absolutely amazing. Awesome stuff. I am mad I ate it all - I want more. Read more
SO GOOD! Love the thin, crispy (almost lightly charred) crust. Definitely reminds me of NJ/NY style. They've got a friendly... staff, quick kitchen, and actually pay attention to Toast orders!! I've had many forgotten dressings or sides elsewhere but NYNYPizza got everything right ???? Also- try the garlic knots. Phenomenal Read more
Perfect local pizza!! Great taste and crunchy crust. It is also worth noting that the slices are HUGE just like NY. I am from NY... so you know this review is LEGIT! Read more
We ordered a medium supreme. What we got looks like a leftover pepperoni pie with a handful of toppings thrown on it. You'd have... to convince me with evidence this "supreme" pizza saw the inside of an oven. Why pay $18.99 for this with so many other optionsin town? Read more
New York New York Pizza is so good. We got a large cheese pie, and buffalo wings. Both choices were delicious ???? Since the day... one I?ve been in Tampa, I keep getting it and it haven?t disappoint me. Read more
Coming from New Jersey in the 90s it took a few years to find a decent Pizzeria until NY Pizza came around. have been a customer... for years and must say that while inflation is creeping up and understand a business has to remain profitable, selling Pizza hasbeen and still is a very profitable business to be in. Sadly, NY Pizza has been reducing their portions and becoming verystingy. I usually order a large pie and what used to a regular cheese, now has to be double cheese to make it decent. Sauce isnow almost not existent as well. Oh my, what can I say, its sad to now pay $22 for a large pie that is no longer half-waydecent. Management, please take note, it is not too late to get back on what NY Pizza used to be. Read more