Reviews for New York Pizza & Family Restaurant in Tannersville, PA

Love love love this place!! The pizza is as good, or better than any NYC slice. ???? The garlic knots are fluffy, yet crispy.... The environment is casual and laid-back. The service is friendly and you feel like family. I wouldn't say it's a "fancy space"(a bit dated) but who needs that in a neighborhood pizza shop!! Read more

I was really happy with the service Ally gave me when I visited in Oct. She was friendly and accommodating to me and my family... needs. The pizza was very good and came very close to a NY pizza. The price for a large pie was very good compared to NY prices.The atmosphere of the dining area was nostalgic to the NY scenery which made me feel at home. I will be visiting again next time I visit the Poconos. Read more

First time there, got seated quickly and server came right over. We got chicken alfredo, the mega burger with fries and the... family sampler. Food was delicious and atmosphere was casual and friendly. Prices are reasonable. Def be back when Im in thearea again. Read more

Im actually from New York and this pizza is the best I have had in pa very good ???????? definitely worth the stop for some... pizza. Read more

Edited my review for the second and last horrible experience. 2 months ago I was sadly disappointed by an ?antipasto salad? made... by NY pizza, and I had talked to the owner who insisted that it?s just the way they make it, which I can except, and he asked meto give them another chance, which I decided to do today and now regret. I ordered an XL pizza, buffalo chicken salad and alarge order of garlic knots. The pizza is good per usual, salad was less then mediocre, but the knots were disappointing. Thevegetable/ olive oil blend was old and the knots were really doughy and mushy. There was no fresh garlic, just burnt garlic atthe bottom of then pan. I called and politely told them that they were disappointing and asked for a refund. The guy I talked towas very defensive and rude and told me he made them himself. I decided not to argue and told him I would bring them back for arefund which I did. When I arrived he told me not to bother coming back to their establishment because of this (I?m sorry, am Ithe one who messed up the food?) and I responded by telling him to cook better food and learn to take criticism better. He wasstill very rude and kept saying things I chose to ignore, and even continued to run his mouth as I was leaving, telling me toleave another review online, so here I am. I feel badly for the family that was dining in your establishment while you chose toembarrass yourself and everyone around you by your immature reaction. To tell someone that they are no longer allowed therebecause you made a mistake and can?t handle the criticism is very unprofessional. But don?t take it from me, there are plenty ofother people who have taken the time out of their day to also comment about how horrible the food can be. I suggest you take anextra 5 minute drive down 611 and go to bartonsville and try Franks Pizza. They gave great food and amazing service unlike thisplace. To the rude guy behind the counter, I hope you find peace in life. Original revie Read more

Though the menu may be large, the food was a hit or miss. Nevertheless, I do appreciate that they deliver and give out generous... portions. The highlights were their perfectly salted fries, as well as their dessert option of Funnel Cake Fries, which wereaddictively sweet! Unfortunately their pasta dishes tasted a bit bland and dried up, although that could just be due to takeout.Either way, this was a decent place to get Italian/American food! Read more

The best place around here to get pizza, seriously the flavor is unrivaled! Not to mention I called the other day with a special... request that they were happy to meet! The heart shaped pizza came out so good. A deliciously cheesy way to ask for a valentine.Recommend this place to everyone! Read more

Omg. Most delicious food all the time!! I am picky so I don?t like most places but this place is great!! Try to order every... weekend. Best pizza. Best fries. Love their appetizers. Love their marinara sauce I always try to get extra. Yummy!! Read more