Reviews for Enrico’s Pizza in Tavernier, FL
Felt like home... And it was mangia mangia delicious! Pizza was amazing! Server was amazing and from northern new York and not... far from where my wife is from... Cook/owner from Brooklyn and was "one love" amazing. Everyone so friendly. We had such a greattime and lunch. Mmm! Read more
Delicious pizza! So good and fresh. We stopped here on the way back home. Prices are very affordable as well. One small pie 12?... was around $12 for pepperoni pizza. Service was quick. Great stop! Read more
Placed my order to go. It's my 1st time here so I kept it simple. One cheese, one pepperoni and the famous garlic bread. When I... took my order home i got two cheese and the garlic bread. I didn't check before leaving because we were in a rush. The pizza wasso good but wish I would of tried the pepperoni too. The garlic bread was different but not bad different. I'm not from thisarea so I will not be able to give it another try. Please check your orders before taking off Read more
We tried the meat lovers pizza, the shrimp pesto pizza, and the truffle garlic knots. Everything tasted great! The staff were... also friendly and helpful. Read more
Visited on 4/26/2022 (long read but good) *The location can sneak up on you as it is near a large white monroe county government... building and their parking is behind their place, be aware. **Please be patient with the staff as with many places there arestaffing shortages As a pizza lover whenever I see a pizza place I try and grab something they offer. - I got a Large 'MeatLovers' pizza for $26. The pizza is roughly a 50-50 split between breading and ingredients, maybe less than 50 on bread. So, Iwould agree it is a good price for what it was, a GOOD pizza! - The pizza is NOT too greasy or dripping, just a good amount fromthe ingredients and oils added to it. When you eat it, you can taste the individual ingredients (e.g. cheese, sausage, pepperonietc.) and not be only tasting bread, it is all there. The breading does not fill you up after one slice like other "name brand"pizza places, even if this had some hefty toppings. - Once you get done with the main section of pizza you are left with theCRUNCH! Not to hard, not to soft, not empty crust, it wont break your teeth when you bite it nor will you have to try andtear/rip it away just bite and consume the crunchy crust or save for later for dipping. Lastly, I would rate this pizza an 8/10and if I used decimals 8.5. While not perfect, it was a smooth and enjoyable experience that fills you up and can have leftoversfor later. Read more
Great little pizza place with very tasty pizza. Service was wonderful, pizza was hot and fresh. For me personally, there was too... much grease on the pizza for my liking but others may not mind. I'd be back for sure. Read more
We were here four years ago. Five weeks after Irma destroyed everything. The woman who served us was so friendly. And the food... was delicious! I'll definitely be back when I'm on the Keys again! Read more
Pizza isn't on my diet, but it was cheat day and my usual pizza joint was closed. I ordered Enrico's for the first time. I got... "The Boss". I was really surprised how good it was. Delivery was quicker than expected, so they scored high for that too. Theprice was fair. I give it Thumbs Up! Read more