Reviews for Times Square Pizza & Bagels in Temecula, CA

The pizza here is outstanding! Hand tossed and delicious. The night I was there, service was weak. The kid at the register asked... me for my order... I ordered 2 pizzas and 2 drinks, real basic... He had to ask me 3 more times, then when the pizzas wereready, I asked for the drinks, and he tells me I didn't order drinks. I replied that I ordered them 3 times. Rather than justhanding me a couple cups, he starts ringing things up again....I had already paid, so I said skip the drinks and took my pieshome..... The pies made it worth it Read more

Visiting Temecula from NYC for a wedding, popped in here on the way out. The Brooklyn Bagel Sandwich was the best bite I had all... weekend and the pizza was solid. Service was great, highly recommended ???????????? Read more

I come to Temecula from Los Angeles every Sunday to visit my son. I came upon this place while looking for a slice of (not a... whole) pizza. As of today, whenever I'm craving pizza and a beer, while I'm in this area, I'm coming here. Big, tasty, thincrust slices, IPA beer on tap, and, excellent service!! Read more

Time Square Pizza is so good. We drive from S. Corona to go here. Never disappointed. The closest to east coast pizza that... we've had in California. Staff is always friendly and helpful. Go! Read more

Moved here from the East Coast,ordered Bronx & Pepperoni pizza, boy oh boy! The crust is crunchy, not salty & most of all NOT... GREASY! It’s even better few days after in air fryer! MY SEARCH IS OVER for the most delicious pizza! Thank you for bringingour NY cravings to Temecula!!! will be back for more! Read more

I’m picky bout Pizza but came into this Spot and John provided excellent customer service as well as suggestions. The Pizza is... amazing and the price is affordable. Will be back sooner than later!! This place is the bizomb. Read more

So happy we decided to check this place out. Hands down the most delicious pizza pie in the area! Highly recommended it. It's... not overpriced either???????????????? Read more

I have delivered food for these folks prior to the Pandemic and today I wanted to show them some love! If you're looking for a... New York Style Pizza with some really fresh ingredients, this is your place! The staff is also wonderful and always friendly!Give these folks a shot if you like thin pizza! Help small business folks!! Totally foldable too ???? Read more