Reviews for New York New York Pizza in Temple Terrace, FL
Great thin crust pizza. Probably the best I've had in the area so far. I wouldn't call it "NY-style" though, as the crust is a... bit different. Delicious, but different. The only thing is that it's a little pricey for a plain cheese pie compared to thosewith toppings. There's only a $2 difference between a plain and a supreme, for example. Don't really understand why it's pricedthe way it is, but hey, who am I to complain? It's totally worth it if you get one of the prechosen gourmet pizzas. Read more
I'm from New York, and this pizza was pretty good, can't lie. Slices are huge and just thin enough. The specialty slice seemed... rather mediocre though, they were really skimpy with the toppings and as a result, over priced. I'd stick with the cheese orpepperoni. Read more
This place has gone down hill. Beyond disappointed. Ordered a large meat lovers pizza which never showed up. We also ordered a... medium cheese which did show up and it was full of garlic we couldn?t even eat it. Idk what?s going there, but save your money. Read more
I used to order pizza from this place online for delivery for while. Last two deliveries were awful. It happened during the... weekend. I order early in the morning and what I got last two times were old pizzas. All they did was to warm them up and hereis your pizza. I know about pizza. I know they were old. I could tell for the texture, flavor and the smell (I could tell andfelt it was fermented). The cheese was dry and no salsa under it. They lost more that one costumer. NEVER AGAIN! Read more
I am the trier of all pizza. In tampa you have so many choices. But this place is numero uno! Tastes just like its from NY and... it's amazing! Excellent cheese flavor! Delicious savory sauce. Read more
Ordered pizza, chicken tenders, and fries. The pizza was great, but the chicken tenders were in pieces. We ate the pizza and... fries instead. The photo provided is exactly what we were given. Why serve customers obvious cut pieces of tenders?? Not okay. Read more
Absolutely fantastic every time! I never stop to write a review but this is my go to pizzeria every time I order in Tampa. Very... good topping portions and the crust always tastes delicious! I ordered a white pizza with onion spinach and artichokehearts. Keep up the good work! Read more
Best Pizza, garlic rolls I have had in a long time. Bye Bye Popa Johns. Can't wait to try Calzone, but since was my 1st time,... went with easy. I think I found my new favorite Pizza joint! *** Update 10/11/22 Tried the baked eggplant parm *** best I everhad*** Read more