Reviews for NYPD Pizzeria At The Villages in The Villages, FL

First time customer today and was pleasantly surprised with the quality of ingredients and attention to detail that went into... preparing our 18-inch, 3-topping, pizza. Flavors were fresh and well balanced. Good chew on the crust and easy to fold andeat! Employees were friendly and working hard to give customers their money's worth. I look forward to the next pie. Read more

We stopped here for a quick bite while out for a drive exploring the area. The pizza slices were huge and delicious. Just got... basic soda drinks. Waitress was very nice, attentive and quick. Nice little stop if you're looking for some good pizza withgreat prices. Read more

First time I?ve been here, ordered a half Italian sub was not what I expected. It was supposed to have a dressing on it but it... did not asked the waitress if I could get some (as well as the soup that didn?t come when the sandwich was brought to thetable), when she came back she stated that it was under the meat on the sub, there was nothing on it. I would order the lentilssoup again but not the sub, because it was lacking meat, very little amount and it was supposed to be hot and it was cold by thetime it was delivered to the table. Read more

So, Overall. This place has great pizza. Being from Longisland, New York and now living here over at the villages- I don?t see... a huge issue with everything other than it?s not exactly like New York pizza. It?s close. But if you want the real deal, This isfairly close to what you?d expect. We got 2 pies, and some wings and some motz sticks, and when I saw these things.. I wassuper super disappointed. They absolutely tasted like they were pre-made and frozen at one point, and for the exact price theycharge for em? you?d expect atlest some level of homemade? Either way- Great place! Super super amazing staff, and good pizza.I?d just maybe pass on these, and stick with basics. Nothing but love over here though! Read more

Service was very slow, there were two waitresses and they seemed busy but did not come back to see us after the food was served.... My wife ordered the veggie pizza and liked it, I ordered a hot Italian hero and it was neither hot or very Italian, very lighton meat and cheese and cold, more bread than anything else. We also added a Greek salad and it was very lacking, mostlylettuce, very few toppings. Read more

Not a great experience. My husband found a long grey beard hair on his pizza. No employees seen wearing hair or beard nets. No... one was courteous, no one said hello or thank you or goodbye. Online ordering didn't work correctly so toppings were addedafter pizza was done, waited 15 more minutes for them. Two 14 inch pizzas were 42.00, plus a 6.00 tip paid in advance withonline ordering. Read more

When I'm in the villages on Fridays this is my pizza spot! Been eating here for years because being a new Yorker I know great... New York style pizza and subs when I eat it. Definitely recommend this place if you're in the area! Read more

For the amount of money they charge you would think its not a problem to actually make you a whole pizza since that's what... you're paying for. Why they took pieces from other pizzas and put together to make my pizza instead of making it fresh, whenfresh is what I paid for. They don't have to worry about me getting pizza from here again and this was my first time gettingpizza from here. Read more