Reviews for Papa Mazzotti's Italian Restaurant in Thornton, CO
Papa Mazzotti?s is a great mom and pop Italian restaurant hidden away in Thornton. I?ve been there several times before and it?s... always very good. This was the Mama?s Italian casserole that comes with a salad or soup, and the cheesecake for dessert?alsoamazing. Read more
Absolutely the best. Best fettuccine Alfredo ever. Sauce was perfect- not to heavy, the perfect amount. The homemade noodles... were amazing. So glad to have stumbled onto this gem. Service was perfect, and homey- just what you'd expect and appreciatefrom a family run business. If you have the chance - don't pass this place up! Keep in mind yes, it's small - it's a familybusiness, and I think everything is homemade. So if you're looking for great food, personal expirence, this is the place! Read more
Absolutely fantastic Italian food. It?s an extremely small place with a few tables and little staff. Scrolling through some of... the reviews on here, I?m not sure a lot of you have had actual Italian food. This place is authentic and great. Only possibledownside, food does take awhile to cook from the time ordering. Not a problem if you?re not in a rush. I?d highly recommendthis place for the food. One of the most authentic places near Denver. Read more
What a great find in a little nook of Thornton most people don't know has some great little business's (Lisa Ann's great too).... Home style Italian for sure with atmosphere to match. Portions are great size, service was exceptional and sure we'll be back.The buttery Alfredo sauce was probably the favorite at our table but I hear the sausage is made locally by family so I'll betrying that next. Salad was simple yet just the right size for a starter and the minestrone soup was light great broth again agreat starter. We shared a cinnamon roll too that was pretty good. Place was great and we'll be back for sure. Read more
Hate to say it, but the restaurant is closed more and more. Called on Friday to confirm open on Saturday. Yes. Went Saturday... and business closed. A shame. Food is always good. Wish they could be consistently open. 5 cars pulled in as we waited for ourparty to arrive. Full house was left to find other restaurants. Really like the family and the food. Will continue to try andsupport this little neighborhood gem. Read more
We've lived 5 minutes away from this quaint little restaurant and have never visited. Food was good as was the service. Only... complaint was the ravioli was a little cold. Tiramisu was delicious! Read more
Got a chicken Alfredo and I would bet $100 that they used canned chicken. It fell apart and tasted just like it, fake grill... marks. It was so soft there was no way it would have survived on a grill. Noodles were undercooked and overall lacked in flavor.My wife got the ziti and it was ?ok?, but really nothing special. I?m honestly surprised at all the positive reviews. Not sureif it?s an off day or what. Read more
Absolutely a gem of a restaurant tucked away in Eastlake. Friendly and thoughtful staff who were serving delicious Italian... favorites. Loved the vodka sauce, sausage and super creamy cheesecake. We also loved the soups. Basically you can?t go wrong. Read more