Reviews for Johnny G's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria in Toms River, NJ

We got wings and pizza. The pizza was mediocre. The wings were just okay. There is nothing that would really make me want to go... back. We didn't finish anything that we ordered. The person working the counter was very nice, the food was the real miss. Theatmosphere was okay, totally acceptable. Read more

Loved this place when I first ordered. The last two times I order from here was a waste of money. I will never be ordering from... here again. I ordered $75 worth of food the first time and the mozzarella sticks were empty and freezer burnt and the wings werestraight salt. This time I spent $56 I ordered a calzone with pepperoni and there was no mozzarella inside straight pepperoniand ricotta and paid extra for cold sauce. Never again will I spend money here!! Read more

Tried this place for first time ordered a calzone with ham after cutting through it 3 quarters of it was cheese and found a tiny... bit of ham in the far corner. When i called instead of understanding the customer they argued there is 4 pieces of ham in it.They don't care that the product they sent was lousy all they care about is defending that they made a good product. Trust me uwould be disappointed too cuzzins is better. I would say go to them from now on at least they care about the customer . Read more

The pizza? great. The people? Friendly. But when you order two pizzas and they say it'll be 30 minutes and you get there a half... hour later and then haven't even started making them? No, thanks. Read more

Poor quality control in this place. Had dinner in the dank dining room. It was warm. Plates and silverware all dirty and we kept... grabbing new sets. Food took over an hour to come out. I had a pasta dish that was literally sitting in a quart of oil. Iwouldn?t come back. Read more

Cousin's lunch party was a hit! Great tasting food, ample portions...the veal parmesan was enjoyed by many. Server very friendly... and attentive. Next get together will be here again. Top notch! Read more

We eat at Johnny G's regularly, on the restaurant side but also on the "get a quick bite" side of the business. The menu is... great, everyone can find something they love, the prices are correct and the portions are generous... enough for 2 meals. Thestaff is friendly, helpful and dynamic. If you ask my wife, just the dipping oil that goes with the bread is worth a trip there! The place could get a make over, the furniture is outdated. But if you want to have a good time, it's the place to be. A lotof people are having it to go as well. In sunday when we went there for Lasagna and pizza, they had a party going on (no roomleft on the restaurant side), so calling ahead to make a reservation might not be a bad idea. Read more

Very disappointing. I ordered a chicken cheesesteak for almost $11. You could barely see anything inside the sandwich, it was... almost all bread. My wife ordered the Chicken Francese with a side salad for $10.40. It was a joke, one piece of chicken and alittle salad for that price. It wouldn't have been enough food for a small child. I feel completely ripped off, I will neverorder from here again. Read more