Reviews for Hilltop Crab House Restaurant & Bar in Toughkenamon, PA

A bar/restaurant with high priced all you can eat crab legs. Some were good and cooked perfectly, but they were mixed with... some over cooked soggy dried out legs you could not snap open. They were just bending like wet noodles. The price is veryhigh and would have been more palatable if the crab legs were great, but that wasnt the case for us. Read more

My family and I were very excited to come to a seafood restaurant in order to enjoy Crab Legs. We made a reservation at the time... of 6pm and arrived about 10 minutes early. We came to find out that we waited 10 minutes past our reservation. Then once we wereseated it took a waitress 10 minutes to come over to our table. When we ordered the appetizers they came about 30 minuteslater.. and the crab bisque soup had shells in it. It took another hour to receive the food that we ordered and the waitress isnot friendly nor came over to our table more than twice throughout the hour and a half. Unfortunately, I have to leave thisawful review as the food was pretty good. Read more

Service here is always top notch. Food is delicious. People complaining about the gratuity included probably shouldn't be going... out to eat in the first place. On our last visit my 4 year old was stung by a bee, and our waitress dropped everything to helpus. Thank you! We'll be back! Read more

Went on Sunday afternoon, was not that busy. Had the big room to ourselves for about 10 mins than bigger group of about 12 ppl... came in. They were rather loud actually left with a headache, the waitress was nice but I thought the service was rather slow. Ithought that the food was overpriced. I got scallop pasta which the scallops were perfectly cooked and good size but I got about5 to 6 of them, I thought the pasta would be linguine like it said on menu but was like spaghetti. Was suppose to be spinach init but seems like it was spring mix cooked which I thought was bit odd. Very little spinach, mushrooms and tomatoes. Not a goodpotion size for 24 dollars. Read more

We drive by this place all the time when we’re heading down to the beach and finally decided to stop and give it a try. It’s... a nice little spot. They are definitely short staffed and the service was a bit slow in the beginning but overall the food wasgood. I had the seafood tortellini with a crab cake and it was delicious. It isn’t a restaurant I would go out of my way toeat at but it’s worth checking out if you’re in the area. Read more

I see a lot of up and down reviews for this spot - I base this review on what it is- a pub with excellent food! Over the years... I've sampled the world famous wings, the excellent cheese steaks, the shrimp and crab legs. I love the food here and lookforward to it every time I'm in town. They've got a great bar, lots of space and lots of parking. I've never had anythingnegative to say about the service nor the takeout pickup. I'm a fan- i think you will be too! Read more

My family was there for the Mother's day buffet. This is the second time we have been there. The first visit was wonderful. ... Yesterday's visit not so much. We had made reservations for a party of 5. We were promptly seated at our table and served ourdrinks quickly. We all went up to the buffet while waiting for the crabs to be delivered to our table. The buffet was mostlyempty and a complete mess. Nothing was cleaned up around the buffet area. Plates, soup bowls and cups for drawn butter wereconstantly empty. We received our first tray of crabs quickly. The crabs were cold and had no seasoning on them at all. Myfamily ate the crabs and then waited over 30 minutes until our waitress came over. We sat with no food (buffet empty) and nodrinks. We then did get a second and third tray of crabs timely which were warm and seasoned. When we received the bill therewas a gratuity already added in. I don't mind paying a waitress well in tips when the establishment and waitress deserve it. Iwas very disappointed in the service and the restaurant yesterday. Read more

Crab imperial was great almost all crab. The gumbo was very tasty had excellent sausage but was a disappointment with very... little crawfish, even a few shrimp would have helped. Very good service. Good craft beer selection. And some good acousticmusic. Read more