Reviews for Joey's Pizza of Hamilton in Hamilton Township, NJ

We ordered from here today and was extremely disappointed. The pizza was old and the cheese wasn?t melted and the pizza taste... horrible. We ordered onion ring, they were burnt, oily disgusting the fries were ok. My stomach started hurting after eating 1onion ring. The pizza was thrown out. We will never order from this place ever again. Read more

Horrible experience not only did they get my order wrong they made it seem that it was my mistake which it wasn?t to make... matters worse one of the pizza guys sitting there staring me down don?t know what that was all about look for the manager orowner couldn?t find him to let him know I don?t appreciate being treated like that as a customer a long time customer whichmight be my last time I see other people have left good reviews and bad reviews but it always seems there?s always a problemwhen I go to this establishment and to pick up my food might be my last time it?s a shame but my allegiance will be with anotherestablishment that treats our customers the correct way Read more

I go back to Marucas on olden Ave With the bowling alley on top. Sometimes the rolling of the balls shook downstairs so much... cheese would slide off your pizza. JOEY'S has brought the product quality, memories & menu back to the FUTURE. Read more

They did not give me what I ordered. I ordered the double crust steak which their website said had ricotta, salami,... pepperoni... but all it had was liquid cheese and beef. It looked like a cheeseburger pizza! Not good! Read more

Their pizza has so much delicious flavor from the cheese to the pizza sauce. Their sauce is one of the best I ever had on a... pizza. The prices are very affordable and they present good customer service. Read more

Very poor service when it comes to using your 10 pizza box coupons definitely was treated differently when ordering paying the... difference because the coupon deal is a plain pizza not what I always order so paying the difference that didn?t bother me itwas the treatment and 90 minutes later standing there and still waiting and watching other customers after me walk in and getthere food. Never before had this issue until I used my free pizza coupons and I still was a paying customer was definitely putat the back of the line and was kept there. This loyal customer will never return ! Read more

Such a great place to have a party. Margarita pizza is to die for! So kind and accommodating. Also a clean and spacious place... for a larger group Read more

First time I went to Joey's Pizza. The pizza is by far the best I ate ever. It seems they do something different when they... prepare their pizzas. We had the medium pizza, half with pepperoni and half with tomato, mozzarella and basil. Very very good.As a starter we had some medium spicey chickenwings, also very tasteful. We spoke a little while with the owner. 30 Years ofexperience. And very special, I have never seen one: a rotating pizza oven with 4 stoors. He didn't want to talk about his wayof preparation and recipes...a secret he wont tell!! Very kind service. All home made products!! Everybody in the neighbourhoodshould at least try a Joey's Pizza. Read more