Reviews for New York Pizzeria Restaurant in Trotwood, OH
The pizza was terrible. We ordered sausage, pepperoni. It barely had any meat on both pizzas.. we called and the manager wanted... to argue with us over the phone. Smh.... Never will we go back there again. We paid $24 Read more
Pizza is great when the instructions of baking the pizza WELL DONE is met I felt very disrespected that today I had to ask for... my money back because I come and buy pizza from here all the time while the cashier just smirked in my face about giving me mymoney back I just feel as if you know me and I come all the time baking my pizza how I like shouldn?t be a problem if I spend mymoney all the time. Read more
I have not been to this place IN YEARS!! I WILL NEVER GO AGAIN!! thinking because it was now supposed to be under new... management, things would be different NO, STILL BAD FOOD, STILL BAD SERVICE!!! paid $38.00 plus tip, 45 Minute delivery TOGET PART of what I ordered, I DID CALL after I received the food, I was told that they can bring what was missing but it wouldtake awhile the (male) that answered the phone needs TRAINING, *MY order Philly CHEESE steak COMBO meal, HARDLY NO CHEESE ON THEPHILLY CHEESE STEAK, no fries, Bread was hard.**** Texas tenderloin combo, it looked like the box was dropped, no flavor,**** PHILLY CHICKEN Sandwich, DRY,, NO FLAVOR. $38.00 LESSON LEARNED NEVER AGAIN. Read more
In case people are curious what size the 24" pizza is, mine was 23"X14". Although I assume the size is supposed to be 24"X15".... Which should give you approximately 360 square inches of pizza. Pretty good value and also tasty. 4/5. Read more
Poor customer service. We ordered via Uber eats. Our driver asked the staff at this location several times if all of the food... had been included bc it looked like way less food than was ordered. They blew her off and pretended not to understand thequestion. Only half of our order was included. Uber eats couldn?t fix it bc the restaurant was marked closed on the app at 9:00on a Saturday night. I called the restaurant and they weren?t able to drive a half mile outside their delivery zone to correcttheir mistake and were rude to me over the phone. Won?t be ordering from this location again. Read more
I ordered the small New York special pizza with the white sauce tonight and it was delicious!!! I've ordered many times and they... are always very friendly and the food is always good too! Read more
New Owner Josh and team is a great addition to the restaurant. Nice folks and good food! Be sure to stop in and dine or get it... to go. Looking forward in trying more stuff..cause huge menu options. Best of luck to you all! Read more
It's very meh. I've tried a few things on the menu. Nothing was terrible, but nothing was super exciting or tasty either. Staff... is always super nice though!!! Read more