Reviews for Shelly Pie Pizza in Turtle Creek, PA
I've been looking for good pizza in Turtle Creek and finally found it! A full service pizza restaurant with great food (20% off... eating in for veterans!) and drink specials during all Pittsburgh sports. Highly, highly recommended! Read more
Pizza is huge, what a great value. If you're in the mood for pizza, give Shelly Pie a try!
I?ve been reading the reviews w my wife after dining in instead of pick-up, hoping for a cooked pizza. It?s been a half dozen... pizzas and always the same; charred, that?s how Shelly describes it, and the rest unbaked. We asked for sauce to the edge toavoid 3? of topping to 3? of crust and the hope the pie would baked through. Even the crust was only close to done. It?s hardto figure when the reasons are ?our oven isn?t working correctly, our pizzas are each unique, we want to train our employees,or did you tell a manager?? For us it?s been the same for too many times. The pizza comes off as thrown together, unbaked,lacking sauce. When so many reviews complain raw, under-baked, doughy; why not fix it? If only we didn?t have to travel toSquirrel Hill for satisfying pizza. We?re done with Shelly?s pie. Read more
Ordered a large cheese pizza and omg definitely got my money ???? worth that pizza was so big and taste good also
First pizza of the year, and it's incredible! I've never had Shelly Pie, but I've heard great reviews and it absolutely lived up... to the hype. It's everything you want in a pizza place: good variety of toppings, good crust, nice sauce, menu items other thanpizza, etc. I tried the classic cheese pizza and a cheese calzone. Both of them were excellent. The pizza is absolutelyhumongous! A large, which is $15, was a whopping 19"! Other places have that size at $22...great deal here! The our crust isthicker than average but it's quality. They are heavy on the cheese, which I personally like. Expect it to be messy as they arealso pretty liberal with the sauce and very liberal with toppings from what I've seen. When the box came I did notice the pizzaisn't perfectly uniform, but honestly, who cares? It tastes great and they use quality ingredient, offer good flavors, andfantastic prices. The calzone was also great. Very large! I shared mine and 1/2 a calzone is enough for a filling meal. It isstuffed with a whole lot of (mozzarella I think) cheese and ricotta. The bread part if the calzone was crispy and had butterand/or garlic in the top. Perfect. Heavy and delicious. The sauce was also wonderful. Came with a whole mini bowl of it, and thesauce had a nice sweetness with some herbs too. Overall, you can't beat these portion sizes or prices. Plenty of high qualityleftovers. While someone in my household didn't love it, I thought it was great (said it looked sloppy and poorly made, butagain, why does it really matter). Anytime I'm in Turtle Creek, I'll try to stop by! Read more
We got the EBUT pie and garlic knots! Insanely huge but plenty of good eating for days after!! Even as delicious cold! If you... truly want some good food go to Shelly Pie!!! Wow eating experience. Read more
We went for the 1st time last night and the food was out of this world good!!! We will definitely be back! Servers, food,... atmosphere were all excellent. If you are in the area definitely check them out! They won?t disappoint and the portions arehuge. Read more
Can not give enough accolades to the staff and especially our waitress. There were 9 of us for dinner and the restaurant was... very busy , but she made us feel pampered , delivered our food quickly, and was very efficient. They are many different menuoptions and we can't wait to revisit. Read more