Reviews for Dutton's Tyler Hill Diner in Tyler Hill, PA

Large servings of everything. We desended on this place on the way back from Xmas tree hunting. 5 vehicles and 11 patrons; they... don't seem to take reservations but we're aware we were coming and had two tables available. They have a good business with manyvisitors coming and going. Should I be back in the area, I'd stop again. Read more

Wonderful retro country diner. Everyone friendly. The kind of place where you say Hi Good Morning to every table no matter if... you know them or not. Prompt service. Good food. Large portion. Fair prices. Read more

Amazing food, huge portions and great prices. We drove 25 minutes out of our way for it and it was worth every minute. The staff... were incredibly nice as well. Pancakes, Mexican omelette and apple pie were all amazing. The coffee was also excellent. Can notrecommend enough! Read more

Food is okay. But really and truly couldn?t have had a more terrible experience with an extremely rude owner and wait staff. We... arrived to a very busy restaurant. About 30 minutes later we were asked for our food order (5 adults). After us, a group ofanother 5 adults sat down and waited to give their order. After about an hour of waiting, the other party who arrived after usreceived their food. When we inquired (perhaps a mistake with the ticket order?) the owner commanded us to ?not pay our tab ortip our waitress- that we would get our food today but shouldn?t return.? If we yelled, I would tell you. I think at this point,it would be reasonable to think that we may have raised our voice? after all we were scolded like children for simply asking whywe hadn?t received our food yet. But, we did not. We spoke loud enough to be head over the busy restaurant but did not ?holler?as the owner claimed we did. She?s extremely sensitive it seems and very controlling, manning the grill like a steam boatcaptain. We care a lot about supporting good businesses with good business owners, and unfortunately this was not it. Read more

I LOVE this place! It's so cute. The food is delicious. Amazing homemade desserts. Really nice folks. Great family story. It's a... bit removed, but it's a pretty drive out there; don't let the location be the reason you miss out. Read more

Great food - the banana pancakes were amazing! Service was super friendly and fast. We didn?t have any pie, but saw the pies.... Wow. Also, check the views out the back window. Hope we get the chance to visit again. Read more

I was so excited to have a breakfast there after all positive reviews, but unfortunately left disappointed and with a sick... stomach. I?ve had pancake that in some parts had huge amounts of salt and honestly tasted like it was on the grill with meat.Worse than that were fries that I?ve ordered with onions- they came with meat- which I haven?t noticed at first but was thinkingit?s just burned parts from grill, until I noticed big chunk. I?m vegetarian and don?t eat meat, when asked waitress she wasn?tsurprised it have meat but just said that everything is made on the same grill and cook probably just scooped everythingtogether. Definitely not vegetarian friendly! Read more

CASH ONLY. Delicious breakfast with huge portions, homefries have crispy bits, plenty of seasoning. Toast was generously... buttered. Pancakes are large enough to feed 4. We will be back! Read more