Reviews for Papa's Brick Oven Pub in Uniontown, OH

Service was absolutely horrible and it was not that busy. People walked in after we ordered and got their drinks and food before... us. Not all of our food came out at the same time. Pizza was okay once we finally got it or else would have rated one star. Pizza and drinks are overpriced. Will not be back. Read more

ALL FOODIES; Must Read... This place is a hidden gem! Literally everything on the menu I've tried in 6 or 7 visits has been... outstanding. Tonight was a shared half-and-half Pizza. We did the Paparoni and the Paparita. The Paparita pizza was likely thebest I've had anywhere. ** It has house made Pesto, fresh mozzarella, tomato, Basil, and a perfect balsamic glaze!! I alsorecommend the Mixed Berry Pecan salad. I can't wait to try the Bruschetta next week! We've traveled all over the country andtried so many 4/5 star resorts, lodges, clubs, etc and this place holds it's own to anyone. Do yourself a favor and give thisplace a try. Read more

Fantastic dinner! Fresh ingredients ? really good!!

Gotta give stars on the good food. However, we were there to use a gift certificate and they kept the rest of the gift... certificate. And warning if you have a gift certificate you cannot order Togo food with it! We learned the hard way. Thewaitress knew nothing about how to use the certificate And when I told her just write a note on the paper size gift certificateshe said she would rather write my name down on a piece of paper and have someone call me back. (I never got a call back.) Iguess I?m going to have to call. Great food though! Read more

Our Papa?s Brick Oven Pub experience was pitiful. My family and I (nine of us) walked in shortly after they opened. There was... only one other table that was occupied upon our arrival. Our waitress was fantastic at keeping up with refills and trying tokeep us informed on our food. The cook staff/management however were a total joke. All nine of us ordered our food together butonly half of us received our food. We waited for an hour and a half before we told the waitress that we wanted our checks. Wenever received our food. Not once did a manager come to apologize. They let the waitress take the fall and try to give us theirpathetic excuses. We will never return and I will be sure to let others know about our terrible experience. Read more

Atmosphere, food and service were AMAZING! Sean was so nice and very knowledgeable and offered great selections for beer and... appetizers. Wish it was closer to home. Definitely a must if in the area Read more

Really nice new restaurant, not super fanci but everything was really good. I had the blackened chicken sandwich, well prepared... and on a good bun, my wife had a meatball thing, I don't know if it was good or not but she was happy which makes it good in mybook. If you go get the pasta salad side dish, it was truly awesome. The waitress was super nice and both of her suggestionswere spot on. The bartender made a nice old fashioned. A+ Experience. Read more

First and foremost to the dude that claims in a review this place is like ?????frozen food quality????? Legitimately should have... their leaving review privileges revoked. I?m from stow not in this area much at all and was told about this place, due to Brownscrowding I ended up back here. I asked the staff what on the menu is good and they said everything lol. I believe it after justa dam meatball sub. To be completely honest, I was so baffled to even see a semi bad review but after reading that ridiculouslyfalse Charlie H. Review?????????.the dude really sounded like it was just a personal dog at the owner or staff. To anyone thathas some time to kill I assure you both the signature mixed drinks (I learned it?s essentially incredible mixology style) andthe food were hands down the best Sicilian food I?ve had in a long time. Some of the best in general, I?d eat this daily if Ididn?t live a half hour away. Wouldn?t be surprised if both the food and drinks win or have won past awards for theirauthenticity especially. Definitely approve and completely recommend. My entire group all think the same.???????????????????????????????????? Read more