Reviews for Annabel's Pizza & Italian Restaurant in Unionville, NY

always good food. We are def. fans

Came as a hiker with my dog. Annabel's is across the street from the spot where the town allows camping. I was able to eat on... the porch with my pup under my chair. Good pizza! Read more

Loved their pizza so much I brought a house one town over.Their pizza make you feel like you eating pizza in the city

Annabel's is always awesome! The owners are friendly and take care of you, the food is very good, and we love the specialty... pizza options. Read more

Great pizza place. Staff was extremely friendly and welcoming. Food was very good. Great garlic knots. Pizza was very good.

Just moved into the area and was so excited to try the food. First order was pizza, a plain and a grandma pie. Absolutely... DELICIOUS. Also ordered garlic knots, so fluffy with a great sauce. The second order was a quick lunch order, sausage andpeppers and Italian sandwich - both were so good, with fresh ingredients. Really loving this restaurant!! Very friendly andaccommodating staff as well. 10 out of 10 from me!! Would have taken more photos, but ate it all too fast!! Can't wait to trymore. Read more

Stopped in for dinner while on a short trip, staying just around the corner at an AirBnB on High Street (Unionville). With very... little restaurant choice in the region, it was nice to have this place so close by. This restaurant was a high 3, low 4stars. We ordered garlic knots, buffalo wings, a slice of pizza, a ham and turkey sub, and two cannolis (one chocolate dipped).The garlic knots were great, hard to mess up. The wings were below average to me, but that's coming from a spoiled Rochester, NYperspective. They reminded me of what we could buy from a grocery store as frozen, fully cooked and sauced chicken wings. Wetried the tortellini alfredo pizza slice, good overall, the crust was a tad weak (again spoiled by Rochester). The sub wasaverage as well. The cannolis were nice and fresh, a good ending to the meal. Apologies for the poor photo quality on a fewshots (camera had a smudge on it for a short time). The staff made up for the average meal; very outgoing, friendly, andhelpful, pushing this review to the 4 stars. The interior was brightly decorated and we were the only ones dining in. Thebathroom was average. Read more

Fantastic pizzas situated a short walk from the Appalachian Trail. Well worth a visit for hungry hikers!