Reviews for Valley Pizza in Valley Cottage, NY

They can put more effort into their food?. Food is just not good. Also, their deep dish pizza is not a deep dish it?s actually a... Sicilian. I ordered a deep dish pizza and got a Sicilian lol. Went there 3 times gave them the benefit of the doubt but it justgot worse. Not going there anymore Read more

I ordered my food at 6:15 it?s now 8 o?clock and my food still isn?t here. I called them 3 times and I just got the run... around.DON?tORDER FROM THIS PLACE THEY JUST DON?TCARE. ???????? Read more

Anytime I'm down in the area I make sure to stop in and grab a slice or something they got amazing little sliders with... everything you can think of and their Pizza is quite impressive and they have Italian ice which is very hard to find thank youguys for being there Read more

Food always great, friendly people you can count on, Chef Tom is the man! We eat from here twice a week. Love the fact that... community kids work there too. A family staple for us. Read more

Food here is amazing. Just had Tom cater my nieces High School Graduation Party & everyone absolutely loved the food. Thought... maybe there would be some leftovers but there was hardly any. The Eggplant Rollenti is to die for. If your looking for realItalian Food look no further. Valley Pizza is the place. Thanks Tom & all his employees!! Read more

Some of the best pizza I have ever had in my life!!! The young lady on the phone named Melody was very kind, and we had a nice... conversation about life before ordering my pizza. I highly suggest coming here for good prices, excellent service, and for awholesome meal. Read more

Valley pizza is horrible! Do not waste your money. The food is disgusting and so is the service. I ordered a simple pie and... garlic knots. The pizza was a mess and the garlic knots were burnt and hard as a rock. When I called to complain the ownerwouldn?t even get on the phone with me. Instead, he could be heard in the background yelling ?there?s nothing I can do about?. Good thing I can do something about it! I?m never going back and neither should you. I wish I could give them zero stars. Read more

I?d give no stars but then I cannot post my review!!! I have ordered from this place so many times, and have never been... disappointed. However, according to the description on the menu the BLT wrap is ?overstuffed? with bacon. Clearly there is nobacon as you can see in the pictures. Then when I call to inquire I am told by the manager who was rude and condescending "wellyou ordered it without tomato, so clearly it's not stuffed". Then he tells me about the pork shortage, so instead of explainingto customers that the meals may be a bit skimpy they send 2 strips of bacon and lettuce in a wrap for $8.50! And then have thenerve to be angry as to why I?m inquiring, and talk to me in a derogatory manner!! Never again!! Read more