Reviews for Aurelio's Pizza of Valparaiso in Valparaiso, IN

I haven't had Aurelio's pizza in quite some time. I think I had it years ago in Joliet, Illinois. Overall pizza was very good,... the sandwich we bought was very good. It's what you would expect from them. I gave atmosphere of five for what reason I don'tknow because really there's only two seats in there. I think it's basically a takeout place. But well worth the money. Thank you Read more

So much goodness. Best sauce best crust. Love all the pizza styles. Thin, calzone,stuffed and thick. Worked at the old... location on billings for 3 years. Only thing I wish they changed was canned mushrooms for fresh. Hope to see a franchise cometo the villages fl. All they have down here is ny pizza :( Read more

I was born and raised in Homewood, IL, the home of Aurelio's pizza. Attended high school with Mr. Aurelio's kids. I drive 130... miles round trip every six to 8 wks to purchase uncooked pies to take home, freeze and enjoy with my family. Valpo owned by theSpillers family, Mr. Spillers is a pleasant guy and his employees are always kind and pleasant also. Read more

This place has always been a delicacy in porter county. Definitely a smaller pizza restaurant/chain and always seems they are... under staffed and out of control when I decide to order food. Love the crust and the sauce they use it sets them apart fromother pizza places but they seem to be stuck where they?re at as a company. Don?t order food through them unless you want towait at least 1-1/2 up and over 2 hours for your food to be delivered. Read more

Eric is amazing! He makes the BEST pizza. I can eat here 3 times a week. And probably do most weeks. All the less that 5 star... reviews are from people who clearly have zero tastebuds or were just having a bad day. Read more

This is the worst pizza I?ve ever had ?????????, the bread tasted rancid, the vegetables tasted like they just opened a can and... pour over the pizza, it had a lot of tomato sauce and also tasted like can tomato, and the cheese was just a little in thecenter of it ????, and this was the works pizza , 6 toppings . we also had wings that tasted like Tyson frozen wings, just plainbreaded with no sauce ????, both cost the same or more than peddlers so never going to order from them again. Read more

If I could give 0 stars I would. The quality of this place has gone way down. I used to get pizza and bosco sticks from this... location at lease 7 times a month. I will never go back. The pizza is under cooked. I got bosco sticks today and they werefrozen still. When I called to let them know the older gentleman that normally answers was a complete d*ck. This Aurelio's isnot good. I would not waste my money here ever again. Read more

After a fishing trip back home, it was great to grab some pizza for the 3 hour trip back to Ft Wayne. Thanks to the great staff... for offering paper plates & napkins when they found out !! YOU ROCK Ever consider moving to Ftw where delicious pizza ? fromthe region? is desperately needed !!! ?? Read more