Reviews for Reinholds Quality Bakery in Waldwick, NJ
The best bakery around!! Love their linzer tarts and their brownies. Everything is delicious
My father used to get his pizza dough from them when I was a small child. ('50s-'60s) my sister and I were there in May and... again this month. First time back in decades. The crumb cake is to die for! Read more
Never buy from a supermarket bakery again. This exceptional family run bakery has a massive selection... and they can make... anything you can imagine. Read more
I have never gone there before and just bought a cake from their for a birthday. The cake was dry and tasted very ordinary,... almost box-like. The lemon custard was alright, but not enough to supplement the dry cake. Would not go there again. Read more
Very disappointing experience, the "fresh" baked cake was stale, ingredients tasted old and the baking was subpar at best. I... read many of the reviews, whatever this place used to be - it no longer is...time for Reinhold's to close. This is not yourgrandparents bakery. Not only were the cakes tasteless, but it would not surprise me if they order in most of theirproducts. Equally upsetting was the fact that we ordered a cake for a special occasion several weeks in advance. The day of theevent we picked it up - not only were the names wrong, their answer was that we should buy another cake and they would add whatthey missed on the cake we ordered. I am a small business owner and I rarely write a negative review, after all, if you havenothing good to say....still, in this case, I feel a duty to warn others. All in all, terrible experience. Not a place in whichI would spend my money. Read more
I bought cupcakes and cookies for some friends. Service was great. Everything looked delicious. I pulled up to the back which is... where GPS led me but the entrance is on the other side in the front. I stayed parked in the back and just walked around to thefront. There is a parking lot in front as well. The bakery has been in business for over sixty years. Very nice! I would goback. Read more
I've been going to Reinhold's since I was a six year old kid in 1966. They had then and still have the best onion rolls, salt... sticks, crumb cake, coffee rings and a diabolical creation known as a Yum-Yum. They also make lovely wedding cakes to order. Mywife and I got ours there and it was absolute perfection. This place is a treasure! Read more
Old school bakery. Everything is absolutely amazing. Everyone who works there is super nice