Reviews for Brothers Pizza & Italian Restaurant in Wantage, NJ
Amazing service and super kind. Ordered for brother in-law and fiance mentioned they were moving and recently engaged. They... went over the top with a few extras and an incredibly kind note. We are so thankful! Read more
Love this place. Moved to Sussex a few months back and I've already tried many different of their offerings and everything is... great. I especially love the specialty pies and the garlic knots are fire ????. Brothers will continue to get my business. Bestpizzeria in the area Read more
Best Pizza in Town, hands down. Their Panini's are great too???????????
I eat here often, always good food, always ready on time. Great pizza place
Ordered a tuna sub and it hardly had any tuna on it. It mostly had lettuce,tomato and and onion. I thought I would share half... with someone at work but a half didnt satisfy. For $9 I expected a generous sandwich. Sorry, but I Was disappointed Read more
This place used to be so good. But it?s terrible anymore. I literally just found a green small bug walking in the lettuce. After... this last chance I tried giving the place I will never go back. That?s just gross they obviously aren?t washing their lettuce.It?s been bad experience after bad experience anymore. Read more
Moved to Wantage, NJ in November 21'. Brother's Pizza was the first food my family and friends had after a long day of moving.... The lady on the phone was pleasant and sympathetic to our transient condition offering us plates, napkins, utensils, and cups.They even remembered us on the next ordered and asked if we were settling in okay, a nice touch. We've ordered here severaltimes and regardless of the day of the week our order is always correct, delivered with a smile, and arrives within a reasonableamount of time. Our very first order came with a welcome note that was handwritten welcoming us to the neighborhood, also a verynice touch. I'm big on loyalty but have given a couple other local pizza shops a go...hands down, sticking with Brother's forthe timing, quality, and accuracy. Read more
OMG I usually stick with the usual take out, veal parm, shrimp scampi I?ve tried so many different things from Brothers, I can?t... recommend anything. Everything is amazing.I never tried cavitell; outside how I make it, I took 2 steps back. A true amazingfood experience Read more