Reviews for Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings in Wantagh, NY

I saw some negative comments about the pizza being burnt and what not but I gave it a shot anyway and this is the best pizza... I’ve tasted so far. Cooked to perfection and tastes, absolutely fresh. I’m sure the guys probably have some off days oncein a blue for those complaining about anything. Read more

Delicious food and great service. We went on Sunday in the early afternoon and we had the whole restaurant to ourselves. The... waitress brought us two garlic knots since it was our first time. We ordered garlic romano wings for appetizer and the Carnivoripizza. The food was amazing. Read more

You can't miss this place! It's right in your face and angled on the street so it can be easily seen. Access to ample parking is... available from both a side street and the main road. Once inside it is quite spacious and table placement offers plenty of roomfor all. No cramping here. And now the food... we had two different types of the roasted wings and an Italian salad. We hadoriginally planned to order a "main course" but the serving sizes were so large that we were completely stuffed!! It was ablessing and a disappointment. We were disappointed we couldn't try additional menu items. The wings were delicious andperfectly seasoned. The salad was amazing with dressing that is among the best I've ever had. We'll be back for sure to try therest of the menu but this experience was definitely 5 stars. Read more

Food was ok, maybe it was an off day, it was 10 dollar regular pie day and my son's birthday and it is one of his favorite... places to get pizza. The best thing we had was the cauliflower pizza, delicious. The regular pie was ok, buffalo chicken pizzawas meh, and the square pie was very meh. We will come back on a different day and hopefully it will be better. Read more

Best happy hour from 3-6 ( on weekdays I believe). Those coal fired wings are truly amazing. They also added their $10 large... pie Wednesdays deal which is great. Read more

We went on a Tuesday night, they offered buy one get one on their great coal fired wings. Also 2fers on blue moon suds.... Wednesdays large pie for $10. Indoor and outdoor dining facilities. Read more

We love to go down on Wednesday nights and join friends at the outside bar ! As busy as your staff always are, you are always... welcomed, with a smile, a nice hello and exceptional service. They truly have such a nice work crew. I have never been made tofeel, as if they’re too busy to wait on me. This is an awesome local town hang out with exceptionally good food. Honestly,I’ve never been stuck with a bad order from Anthonys coal fire. Thanks for the good work Anthony’s.. there’s just alittle some extra specialness when we come in on a Wednesday, or any other day for that matter. A smile, or a Pleasant waitstaff or bartender, certainly holds a lot of weight in today’s times . Kudos and thank you!! MA caddigan Read more

Great Anthony’s salad, very affordable prices, good service, social distancing and famous chicken wings. For me personally it... was a little bit burned. I can’t have little black coal pieces in my mouth. Sorry. But I know for sure some people love it.So, people it’s up to you. Read more