Reviews for Gatsby On The Ocean in Wantagh, NY
1,000 star review!! Our wedding wouldn’t have been what is was without it being at the Gatsby. We settled for a cake design... since ours couldn’t be done, (or so we thought) Elyse found this out somehow and surprised us on our wedding day with theexact design we wanted. If you want it the Gatsby will get it done! Guest asked how I was so laid back the day before/of andit’s become the team at the Gatsby KNOW what they are doing. If it’s between the Gatsby and another location for yourwedding/event choose the Gatsby! The photos below were all taken right next to the venue also! Read more
ABSOLUTELY AMAZING!!!! Just had my wedding here recently. Always wanted to have a beach wedding and it was a DREAM COME TRUE... that has become a reality for me and my husband. That day went so super smooth, I was not stressed or worried about anything.Elyse you have done a wonderful job for making our wedding day such a fun and exciting experience. Gatsby has absolutely wentabove and beyond for giving me and my husband the best wedding experience. Food was delicious and fantastic. If we could eatanother round we would. All the staff was wonderful and sweet. They were always there to help when needed even if we didn't askfor it. All our guests really loved the atmosphere and was really impressed that they got a bit of everything of the overallplace. Me and my husband couldn't agree more if we could relive this wedding again, we would love to do it again. Our familyand other guests has not stopped talking to us about everything on that day. From the food, the service, and the smalldetails. If there is an option for a 10 star I would definitely rate this place that number. So thank you very much Gatsby fordelivering the best wedding experience. :) Read more
Very pleasantly surprised .Service was wonderful.. no waiting at all. Baked clams and buffalo cauliflower were both really... tasty. Main dishes which were chicken piccata and lobster ravioli were also very good.. definitely no regrets! Read more
We very much enjoyed our visit to Gatsby's when we went to Jones beach. The staff were pleasant...especially Elena and John and... the food was delicious. When we parked we paid $25 which went towards our food tab. Beautiful setting and quick access to thebeach. The only thing I wish is that they had gluten free options but overall a great experience. Read more
The ambiance is incredible and the staff are wonderful. I was there for an event and overall it was well done. The food was... standard, nothing overly special but not terrible. Overall a nice place for an event. Read more
Beautiful venue. The Gatsby held an American Bridal Expo and my company was a vendor there. You and me by the sea Travel. The... staff take great pride in making sure you have a spectacular event. Read more
If you want to have a party at Jones beach this is the spot. Always love coming here and seeing familiar faces. Keep up the... great work! Read more
We had our wedding here Sept 1, 2022. It was more than perfect. Elyse, Ron and all the staff were so awesome to us and our... families and friends. They went above and beyond to make the day calm, special and flowing perfectly. The cocktail hour wasspectacular on the veranda during the beautiful sunset and the event room held our 150 adult guest and 11 kids and 4 babies withmuch room to spare. We had 2 bridal suites to get ready in and for the babies to rest in. The food was EXCELLENT, 5 stars!!!! Somany people told us it was the BEST wedding they'd ever been to and we absolutely agreed! Thanks Elyse, Ron and everyone who wasthere that night, you guys are amazing! Read more