Reviews for Hemingway's American Bar & Grill in Wantagh, NY

Great atmosphere! Excellent food! Incredible service!

Been here multiple times. Always on the edge of greatness. Tasty and prepared well, but food should come out hotter (mashed... potatoes actually cold in center). Accommodating staff and friendly service. Read more

The place was very clean and the staff were lovely and very attentive to their tables. Very nice selection of food but the... french toast and potatoes,were just warm and the sausage was very dry and cold. At $30 a person it was not worth it as it onlyincluded coffee and no cocktails. The chocolate moose was a lovely light breakfast moose which saved the day. Read more

Yummy food. Very pleasant service. Not as big a selection as i had remembered.

Finally ordered the braised short ribs and they were excellent. Practically melt in your mouth. Atmosphere is always welcoming... and cozy. Service was great! Read more