Reviews for Margarita's Cafe Smithtown in Wantagh, NY

Our go to Mexican place. You can always expect delicious food, great drinks and really friendly staff. We love sitting at the... bar sipping on margaritas. Any of the Willy's are great. Read more

Love the vibe! Everything was fabulous! The only down fall was the food. It wasn't real Mexican food, more so of a modern type... of Mexican food. Huge let downer but other than that everything was great! Read more

I just left the restaurant. If I could give negative stars I would. The only reason we didn't walk out is because my son... had.to eat and it's late. Upon arriving, the hostess was pleasant and said we can sit anywhere. We took our seat, water wasgiven after about 10 minutes sitting there and after 15 minutes the waiter came. He didn't introduce himself, didn't greetus...just walked up to the table and said "what are you having to drink". We ordered our drinks and guacamole. Guacamole came2 minutes after he left and was made literally in one minute. $15 for not even 1 avocado that lacked flavor and was poorlymashed. We sat for another 20 minutes waiting for our drinks. My husband asked the waiter where the drinks were and was toldthey had to go in the back to get it? 10 minutes later our drinks come out and he finally takes our order. 20 minutes later ourdinner is served. Not once did the waiter come to ask us how everything was or of we wanted a refill on our empty drinks or ifwe needed anything. Food was simply okay but service was terrible. I asked for our check and when we paid, the waiter simplydropped it on the table and walked away. Not a thank you, or have a nice day or anything. Dropped the check and walked away. I chose to come here today for my birthday bc a few years ago, I had a good time. Today, not so much. I understand the worldis short staffed but there was a.manager standing at the bar talking and hanging out while other staff members ate. If it wasa tough night ask for help of have him jump in. Also, it doesn't take more than 10 seconds to properly greet or thankcustomers. Needless to say, we will not be back. Read more

Delicious food with friendly staff. Ambiance is fantastic. Genuine south of the border feel. Storefront is good but but doesn't... represent the hidden treasures within. Visit. You'll definitely come back! Read more

First time here. Great food and drinks. Definitely will be coming back

Omg the food was so good. Perfect day to eat outside. They have great drink specials after 4pm if your interested. Definitely... going. Ack there where so many different dishes I wanted to try and if it's anything like the fajita combo I got then wow. Thestaff was so friendly and amazing the inside was clean and the atmosphere was beautiful. Inside and out. The bathrooms wherewell maintained which I always appreciate. Read more

OMG.....I just passed by this place a week prior and it looked nice and figured I'd give it a try. The Food was seriously so... good. I started with a special Margarita and the loaded Nachos. Then we had the beef empanadas, which were good and verycrunchy. Overall the food was delicious and the ambiance was so pretty and the place smelled brand new. The staff was veryattentive and fast and friendly. Seems like a hidden Gem to me. I also have friends in the area that spoke very highly of thisplace as well. Definitely check this place out. And also....the churros were delicious!!! Read more

Nice place with a very traditional Mexican atmosphere and music ????????. Delicious food, very welcoming staff. Portions are... literally huge. A very big choice on the menu. A lot of Halloween decorations and colors in the place. Good prices ?. And it wasnice to get chips with tomato sauce for starting. The only one thing doesn’t match to this place is a ladies room, which couldbe nicer. Especially this year when people don’t want to touch anything another time. Thanks for staying in business. Read more