Reviews for Mill Street & 5 American House in Waterdown, ON

Went there for an early dinner Saturday night. There were so many delicious selections to pick from. I had the fish and chips... and it was amazing . The prices of meals are very reasonable and the portions are very generous. The staff is warm andwelcoming. Our server was Katie and she really added to the enjoyment of our time there. I will be going back there very soon. Read more

First time Visiting Mill st & 5 Our Very capable Server was Lindsay who looked after us and was Very Knowledgeable. The... atmosphere was great, it has the decor of an awesome place for Families to visit. The Food was plentiful and Delicious and weare looking forward to our next visit. Read more

Good food, great service and one of the best live bands I've heard in years! We definitely will be visiting again!

I got the chicken fusilli, my boyfriend got the schnitzel and we shared the escargot. For drinks we got Caesar?s. Everything was... superb. Will be coming back again! Read more

Nice pub decor and the staff was very friendly and helpful. The Caesar drink perfect and the wings cooked perfectly.

Went for the jerk chicken and ran out within 45 mins of it starting. (When we got there) Not sure how much they made but I... didn't see anyone else with any so maybe they only had like 2 meals or something. Felt like a bait and switch. Also didn'thave the side with the curry so swapped it with garlic bread. Odd.. Curry was very bland. Totally without taste. Overall, notimpressed. Wanted to like it as it's down the street but it was very underwhelming. Read more

A nice comfy pub. Service was friendly and welcoming. Food and drinks were great.

Wings were good but the burger poutine was exceptional...as was the creme brule... service was friendly and the food came out at... a good time...thank you, Mill St. & 5 American House, for a great lunch experience! Read more