Reviews for The Elias Inn Supper Club in Watertown, WI

We went for the Friday fish fry. The atmosphere was good. The waitress was great, very attentive. The food needs lots of... help. The drinks needed work too. We ate at another supper club, in town, and it was so good. This was a very disappointingexperience. Read more

I had a great meal from the Brandy Old Fashioned to the Schaum Torte. Wish I took pictures! Had reservations for 4 and got in... no problem. Hopping place. Prompt and friendly staff. Loved the relish tray, fresh salad, highly recommend the French onionsoup! Had the steak special and baked potato. Really don't mind paying for a wonderful meal, oh and my first schaum torte...sogood. Treat yourself! Read more

Well I think for a Friday fish fry and I liked the chicken better than the fish. The baked cod is not served with melted butter.... The waitress only check on the table after most of food gone or cold. My opinion is I like pumpkin center fish fry better. Read more

Excellent service! Casual laid back vibe. Loved the traditions of a supper club service. The bread was warm and served with the... garnishes on a lazy susan, the soup and salad were just ok. The scallops with risotto were very nice and prepared well. Enjoyedthe stuffed shrimp and rice. Wrapped up the meal with crème brûlée. Overall a nice meal. Read more

Elias Inn has a great environment, and has a great German-American supper club feel. The steak was phenomenal, and the shrimp... was decent. We had to wait a little long imo, and it was a little loud, but otherwise a great place for a nice dinner. We lookforward to returning to the Elias Inn Supper Club sometime soon. Read more

Honestly, we were super let down by this place. First off we went on a Friday night and didn?t find out they do not have a full... menu on Friday nights until after we waited for our table, sat down and ordered drinks and then the waitress told us that it isonly family style fish and chicken on Fridays. The hostess didn?t say anything nor did we see any sign by the door, host standor bar area where we waited stating this. This was a huge bummer to my husband who was looking forward to their more Germanstyle food menu. We stayed and sadly the fish and chicken were nothing to rave about. For a Wisconsin fish fry, I definitelywouldn?t return here for the bland fish. We shared a tray of potato salad, beans, bread and coleslaw. The fries weren?t warm atall when served to us. Our brandy old fashions were good but our glasses sat empty while we ate and our waitress never offeredto get us another. I also found it odd that she didn?t offer any refills of sides. For 4 people the small bowls of potato saladand coleslaw seemed so odd and they were all emptied quickly. Great cozy atmosphere but all in all, it was a sad experience fora supper club. Read more

I recently visited the Elias Inn Supper Club for a Friday Fish Fry and was pleasantly surprised to learn the Fish Fry includes... Fried Chicken, Fried Cod and Baked Cod served family style with the sides featured on a Lazy Susan. All the food dishes servedwere very good along with the service. The restaurant does get quite busy on Friday so be prepared for a wait. The Elias InnSupper Club does unfortunately fall short on the value scale as the only Fish Fry option available is all you can eat. 4.0 (5.0if you typically order all you can eat). Read more

Cozy, quaint place with traditional supper club food. The whole night was an experience, from drinks at the bar, to the relish... tray, to soup/salad, to the entree (with sides), to finally dessert. The staff know how to make your dinner perfect, the food isa gastronomic delight, and the ambiance makes you all warm and fuzzy. 10 stars!!! Read more