Reviews for Buckatabon Tavern & Supper Club in Wauwatosa, WI

My friend and I tried this out today. I have to say once You get inside it reminds one of the older times when old diners had... things all throughout the restaurant. I thought the environment really brought back good memories of the gold ole days. Theservice was great! The waitress we had really was thoughtful and make the experience that much better! The food quality wasgreat! I would come back here again for sure! Read more

Came for brunch on a beautiful Saturday morning. Chose to sit inside cuz the sun was so strong and didn't regret it. Service... was excellent as were the bloody mary's and all of our meals - plus it's right next to the farmers market which is always fun towalk around. Seems like it would be a cool bar to hang out at also, but that's for another time. Recommend the breakfast! Read more

This place was amazing!!! Drinks were good… food was amazing and a great price for what you got!!!! Our server Reese was... definitely the highlight of the evening very friendly and knowledgeable about the menu I feel she definitely went above andbeyond she also Answered my 100 questions about anything and everything!! We will definitely be back while she is working!!!!It was a great experience Read more

Lovely restaurant with a great atmosphere. Good for date nights and fun nights out with friends! You get a complementary... appetizer plate and delicious water. I'm definitely going back again. Read more

A quintessential Wisconsin supper club! The best prime rib I’ve ever had. It has a little chimichurri sauce on it. Get... it! The old fashioned was correctly made and delicious. Drink it! The bathrooms are spotless with some relaxing north woodssounds. Use it!! Finally, a shout out to Natalie and Jenna. Very attentive and fun servers. Keep up the good work! Read more

First time to this new place and food, drinks, and service were all good! Great location, right in the middle of the Village!... My friend ordered a juicy burger and I went with the Turkey Pesto Croissant. We both had the Teddy Bear Mule. So good! Ourserver was friendly and attentive. Great lunch experience! Read more

We had so much fun dining in our shanty tonight! Natalie and James took such good care of us and the food was AMAZING! Loved the... cheese curds and deviled eggs as starters. I had the ribs which were fantastic…and the cornbread *chef’s kiss*. Woulddefinitely recommend this dining experience! Read more

Stopped by for lunch as the place looked cool online. Was not disappointed. Had wedge salad and a Manhattan Earl. Was more... than impressed. Love to come back for a nice posh dinner. Read more