Reviews for Pizza Man Milwaukee in Wauwatosa, WI
Ragu was salty! Then changed it up to spaghetti and meatballs. Some of the Spaghetti meatballs were still raw inside. Pretty... expensive chicken alfredo since you have to pay extra to add meat. Calamari seems to be deep fried with burnt oil maybe becauseit has been reused too many times. I would of been safe at Olive Garden instead. Read more
Although the place was very nice, I will not go there again. We ordered a medium margarita pizza. 20 minutes later something... came to our table and it has nothing to do with a pizza. Some cheese and a few tomatoes on a burnt, greasy and tasteless dough.Not worth $18. Moreover, the employees were quite indifferent. I do not recommend. Read more
Pizza came cold and Vegys were raw and not cooked at all. Very little sausage too. Disappointed to say the least. This was a... sausage pizza with green pepper , onions mushrooms and tomatoes ?????? worse pizza I ever had for a home delivery. NEVERAGAIN!!! Garbage pizza ! Everything was so under cooked and cold I took off the tid bits of sausage that was put on my pizza soI wouldn’t consume RAW MEAT. Very dissatisfied. Took one bite and threw the rest out. Want my husbands money back. To theowner no need to reply to your response sense your response seems to be the exact one every customer gets. Restaurants shouldserve food cooked to perfection each time to every customer. The first impression is the most important to bring back acustomer. There is nothing you can do or say to bring us back or order for home delivery again. Read more
I normally don't write reviews and also I understand covid changed a lot of things and the pressure but i couldnt stop myself in... this one , we recently moved to Wisconsin and decided to try pizza man at the tosa location the reviews were mixed but we stilldecided to go and boy We REGRET. We ordered a take out king-roni , victory, bianca nd chesse curds costed about 85ish vch justflew off the window. I understand thin crust ,( i travel across country frequently nd have been eating thin crust so i know forsure this is not ever remotely close, this i have no words the pizza looked nd was super super dry nd super toasted crust tastedlike so chalky super weird sply the crust it was awful had to wonder did thwy just gave us some ones left over order honestlythgh might not be the case it felt like tht , cheese curds super salty and soggy othe herb dippings was the only good thing inour order . Not worth ur bucks nd trip wouldn’t recommend at all sorry pizzaman , how can u mess pizza special THE CRUST whenu literally have “ in CRUST we trust ”???????????? in ur branding… Read more
Loved the pizza (except the outer crust was cooked very brown), loved the atmosphere and the server!! My son enjoyed The... cheesecake and chicken alfredo! Read more
Got the Topher pizza and it was delicious! The cheese curds are also pretty dang good! Highly recommend visiting!
Met with friends after work to catch up. Didn't have the pizza but the eggplant fries and cheese curds were great. I'm looking... forward to returning to try the pizza. I heard it's tasty. Read more
I’ve never been disappointed w/pizza man. Today was ridiculous. That’s the cheese garlic bread, yes they took it off the... bill w/out me asking, however they didn’t apologize for the terrible attempt to pass that off as cheese garlic bread, when Igot home and tried it, the bread was very dried out. my wife’s pepperoni pizza is also missing a lot of cheese. And the“guy” behind the bar(don’t know what he goes by) kept running his hands threw his hair. That is not hygienic when you’retouching people food and drink. Read more