Reviews for Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings in Wayne, NJ

I went to this place with friends a few weeks ago. We had such a great time with good food. Bar tender Melissa did a great job... making us feel welcomed and was always available when we needed her. Five Stars. Read more

Terrible and overpriced. Service is a bunch of high schoolers who are clueless. Our waiter was sitting at the bar eating food.... Soda machine was broken. Save your money. Food took forever to come to our table. Tasteless. I thought a 900 degree oventhe pizza should come out faster? Tables are sticky. Server said the tables were used outside that’s why they are sticky?Frozen supermarket pizza is better. I bet the pizza dough comes in frozen. Not a good thing to say. Why I went hear is beyondme. I gave the place a second try after a bad experience a week ago. Never again. So many great pizza places in Wayne. Anthony Franco, Positano’s and Brother Bruno. Take this place off your list. Read more

I love their ribs & chicken wings. Great spot to watch the football game. Good atmosphere, had a great time will be returning.

It’s often difficult finding “your” local bar in your community. My friends and I were enticed to try Anthony Coal Fired... because of the 2 for 1 beer offer and were pleased by the selection of beer available. While we went for the deal, we didn’texpect to find our community bar, especially from a chain pizza place. The staff have made the difference and have created awelcoming and friendly atmosphere. Melissa is a great bartender who anticipates customers needs and keeps the bar runningsmoothly with the Isaac keeping up with the hectic pace of the restaurant, making sure everyone has what they need while alwayskeeping a smile on his face. Read more

I can’t say enough about our experience tonight! We brought a big party of high school graduates from our youth group to... celebrate and they took care of us. I called a few times in the last couple of weeks to inquire and set everything up fortonight. I spoke to a couple of people who were all amazing. Not just nice and polite, but overly kind and helpful. Theyaccommodated my request to do a catering package while eating at the restaurant so it would be easy with the large party. Thegeneral manager Louise is the ABSOLUTE BEST! She was extremely helpful through the whole process and went above and beyond theentire time. She made sure we were getting the best deals and looked out for the customers. We set up the menu ahead of time andeverything was easy and stress free when we got there. She just made sure everything happened and we got to enjoy ourconversations. Our server, Victoria, was phenomenal! She was attentive and sweet. Even when she was taking our drink orders,she was advising another server how a regular client likes their drink. You can tell they really care for their customers andwant to create the best experience for everyone. The food was delicious and plentiful. We had Anthony’s classic salad, themargarita pie, Carnivori pie, Buffalo wings, classic pie, garlic knots, meatball pot, cookies and brownies. Not one thingdisappointed us! We have been here once or twice in the past, but kind of forget about coming here. But after tonight, theyleft a lasting impression on my husband and I and we will definitely become regulars. Read more

I am extremely disappointed and dissatisfied with this place. What really irks me is that they would give food to their... customers like this but probably wouldn’t eat this themselves. Both boxes of garlic knots were burnt and drowned in oil.It’s an absolute waste of money especially during these times. Read more

Love this place. The best Happy Hour of all time and the best Bartender of all time. I’m not sure what her name is, but I... think it is Melisssa. She works Monday to Friday from 3 p.m. to close and some full days. She is awesome and everyone Lovesher. A lot of regular Customers come just to interact with her. She has a bright Future with your Company. She should becommended. Read more

Came here for the first time and left disappointed. Service was not great, food was bland and entrees came out at different... times. Was expecting to get our appetizer first but my husbands entree came out before and then the appetizer. While both mydaughters and I waited 30 min for our entrees. During that time the server barely interacted with us. When asked why entrees didnot come out together I was told they bring food out when it’s prepped. I’ve worked in the food Industry and know thatappetizers are put in first and then the entrees to ensure everyone gets their foods at the same times. Definitely will not becoming back. Our experience was all but positive from beginning to end. Read more