Reviews for Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria in Webster, NY
Ordered pizza for my son?s birthday. It took over an hour to arrive and it very clearly had been dropped. Most of the toppings... were off the pizza, wedged into a corner of the box. I called to let the store know and was told I would be given a credit on myaccount for another pizza. Called tonight to try and use this credit and was told they had nothing on file and couldn?t doanything for me. The ?manager? was clueless and I have a hard time believing it wasn?t just another random employee they put onthe phone. Read more
Always a friendly face at the bar and behind the bar. Plenty of televisions to watch your game. Cold beer and great... food. Update 08.10.2022: Outdoor deck, patio is covered and heated. Great local place. Amazing full menu. We just had a workevent there 18 people and all was wonderful. Read more
The guy literally made up an excuse that the order ?was not in the order list? or something. Then our coupon didn?t work right,... and we ended up sitting there for 2 HOURS. And he never refilled drinks, he disappeared for 1 hour, and kept making mistakes.BIG waste of time. Read more
Same great taste as always! When I come back to town, Salvatore's is a must have. Maybe it's the nostalgia, but it's damn good... pizza to me! Read more
Placed a delivery order today for 1 Medium cheese 1 Gluten Free 1 boneless wings and the total was $50.00. We were ordering... food for our family which includes three small children. When placing the order nothing was relayed to us that cash was not thepreferred payment method. Salvatore?s took our order and when it was delivered I was going to pay with cash. I was paying with alarger bill because that?s all we had. The person who was helping us at our door told us our total and when I handed them thebill he told me that he didn?t have change to break a large bill. We were turned away because I didn't use a card to pay with. Iunderstand there is an on going COIN change shortage but how does a driver not have money to give out change? You couldn?t roundup to the nearest dollar? So tonight my three young children will not be eating before their sports because of this. I?mappalled that this was not notified to us before making the order so I could use the correct form of payment. He told me ?do yougo around paying with $100 every time you order a pizza??? Oh I?m sorry the order was $50! Does he go around not having changefor his customers all the time??The driver also drove away with our order refusing to take our money. After he left I called tospeak to a manager and all they did was apologize for the inconvenience. An apology doesn?t give us the food we ordered. We willnot be returning. Read more
Burnt ends This is their chicken parmigiana I ordered that I paid in total $19. When I asked for a credit because my chicken... was burnt, they offered me $6.95. They told me thats all they could offer since only the Chicken was burnt, not the pasta andsauce that came with it. I told them instead of the refund, I prefer they make it again. The second pic is the remake. Read more
Always consistent and delicious. Used to be strictly Mark's but have converted. Great thin pizza. Only downfall is that they are... a bit more expensive but the rewards program and a pick up window (saves fees etc on delivery) make it tolerable. Read more
We had an anniversary party at the Bay Road location, it was awesome. Indoor seating, enclosed patio and outdoor seating,... delicious food, incredible staff! Read more