Reviews for The Wicked Oyster in Wellfleet, MA
My wife and I had oysters, muscles, and the half chicken. All we're really good, our server was fantastic very personable
Food was amazing. I got the lazy lobster and it was great as well as the other meals at the table. However, the service was... insanely bad. We made a reservation and proceeded to wait 35 minutes for our table. Once we were seated the wait was notacknowledged at all by the server or management. We had to wait at the table some more for waters to even be brought out and ourorder to be taken. We ordered drinks, bread, and entrees. The bread only came out once we got our meals and explicitly had toask for it. After ordering, our server never came back to check on us until our meal was ready. Once again, was not apologeticin the slightest about our wait, or anything. We did have a late reservation, and understand staff can get tired. However, ifyour servers won't actually serve after 8 o clock, don't take late reservations. Read more
We are outdoors on a pleasant summer evening. Overall ambiance was very nice and relaxed. The food was typical boring mediocre... preparations made with excellent local ingredients, so kind of a mixed bag. Cocktails were watered down and obviously made bysomeone in a rush. Oysters were almost room temperature when they arrived. It wasn’t great, but I’m clearly in a minority asmany people seem to like this place. Read more
We hit this place on a very busy Friday night when Ptown restaurants were closed. So our experience may not be typical. That... said, this place was okay. The service was a bit slow (understandable) but very friendly. I think the bartender was trying tomake the wait easier by really amping up the drinks. Sadly, our light tan rum & coke was almost undrinkable. The food was freshand well prepared but overall the menu was limited and uninspired. My $38 stew was 3 shrimp, 7 mussels and a couple of clams ina light tomato sauce. Nice place. Not a must-see. Read more
Stopped here after bypassing the overcrowded establishments in town. We were very glad we did because we had fresh local... oysters, a delicious seafood stew and lightly battered and fried accompaniments. There were good wine- by-the-glass selections(nicely chilled white!) and a comfortable interior for a warm summer night. Looked like there was a pleasant patio area too ifthat's your jam. Prices seemed reasonable for the area. Read more
We dined on the outdoor patio with our dog. The outside area is so cute! The drinks were yummy, wine selection was impressive... and food was good! Our oysters were not served chilled which was my only complaint... Everything else was fantastic. Read more
The Wicked Oyster is one of the best, most authentic restaurants on the Cape! THE.FOOD.IS.INCREDIBLE. End of story. The menu is... extremely diverse with fresh, local flavors and amazing creativity. The cocktails and wine are also fantastic. My husband and Ihosted our rehearsal dinner here in September and Ken, Eliza and the whole team made us feel so special. We booked the event inthe fall of 2020 when there was so much uncertainty and they were so extremely flexible, accommodating and communicative everystep of the way. Every single one of our guests loved their meal. They even went above and beyond and printed custom menus forus with our names on them and gave us extras that I will be using in a scrapbook! Just so thoughtful. We are Wicked Oyster fansfor life! Read more
The clam chowder was creamy and full of flavorful clams and bacon. The cod gremolata was sweet and tender with a delicious... lemony sauce. The oysters on the halfshell were extremely fresh and briney tasting. The staff was helpful yet gave us spaceto enjoy the evening out. Read more