Reviews for Old Fashioned Ice Cream in West Babylon, NY
This was my first time after passing this place for 10 years. The price is high like every where else right now. Did not like... the sour sop it was blah. Loved the grapenut. It was a little too sweet for me. So this has a be a once in awhile treat insteadof a weekly one. Read more
It's amazing how popular this OFIC as they called themselves are. We got there after 8 pm and there was a line to get in the... store to order. It's understandable because inside the store is very small. The store is not setup for indoor dining and notsure if they deliver or take online orders. Why would they, It's perishable merchandise subjected to melting very fastregardless of dryice technology. This store can be seen from a vehicle in normal traffic and has parking andwheelchair-accessible entrance. They sell ice-cream; need I say more -- many assortments of flavors and t-shirts and water andcakes. Read more
All home made all the time. This place is incredible. Staff always issues service with a smile. They got flavors that I have... never tasted before. They even have Strawberry ice cream cakes y'all. Worth the wait, travel, and price. You won't bedisappointed. Read more
Best ice cream place! Very friendly customer service, feels very welcoming as soon as you walk in. The place is nice and clean.... There are so many flavors to choose from. The ice cream is always fresh and delicious. Way better than all of the rest!! A++++ Read more
I am almost 50 & I?ll always remember my grandfather bringing us here in the back of his pick up truck or my dad would bring... home sundaes on his way home from work. Years later, my friends and I would ride our bikes to get a cool treat. Pregnancycravings with both of my children and a sweet treat with them on a hot summer night when they were older. I now live in NorthCarolina and wish so badly I could take a quick drive over to Old Fashioned Ice cream. Was sitting here thinking about thisplace and saw it survived the pandemic & all the businesses closing. So happy to see you guys are still there! I hope I can comehome and visit soon. It?s been over 5 years. My longest break ever from the best ice cream! Read more
I love this place! My favorite ice cream spot. We love their ice cream pies!
The ice cream is phenomenal!! I?ve been coming here for years and just can?t get enough! And it?s all made fresh in store! The... service is always fast & friendly! & all of the workers there are super super nice!! My favorite flavor is their chocolate Oreowith whip and a cherry. Definitely stop by if you?re in the area :) Read more
After driving past this place for years,finally stopped and bought some ice cream. OMG! There is no other ice cream store like... this one! Fantastic flavors! Incredible ice cream! My favorite was the banana! Read more