Reviews for Jersey Mike's Subs in West Caldwell, NJ
Staff is quick and generous with the meats. You have to try the jumbo triple chocolate cookies!
My sandwich was made with some love the day I went.
Best Jersey Mike's ever! We are a customer for life! My daughter had been very sick for awhile and when we mentioned one night... that we were bringing her a sandwich to the hospital the young girl behind the counter wouldn't accept any money for thesandwich. We would never even expect that especially from a young person. It seems to be the "Jersey Mike's Way." We alwayslove the subs from JM and this time was no different. My daughter requested them often and they seemed like the only thing shewould eat and like. Thank you Jersey Mike's. Class act! Read more
Filthy....the slicer and everything else had all types of meat and cheese everywhere. The guy making my salad was nice but was... distracted by a coworker. Look dude let him prepare my salad! You talking over my salad grossed me out!!! Spit flyingeverywhere!!! I threw it out! No thanks ..I'll continue to make the drive to Clifton. Read more
Shout out to the staff and management at this Jersey Mikes. Everyone there is super nice and personable. I lost my money at the... shop (won't disclose amount) but I remember it was the last place I went too. I went back there hope a good person saw it andturned it in. I was sad and kicking myself for letting my mind get the best of me. But management really took the time to speakto me and that is all that matters. Read more
Great sandwiches...we always buy a large sandwich and end up splitting it. Great portion for two people. We have tried numerous... different types and love the Turkey Club 'Mike's way'! Read more
There seems to have been a Staff change and the atmosphere and attitudes of the workers are night and day better than the past.... Will definitely be visiting this location more often now! Read more
I visited this location Dec 7th 2022. The smell upon entering was awful. I couldn't figure out what it was but there was an... unkempt customer taking a nap at one of the tables - perhaps that was it. The smell was so bad I couldn't eat inside. There wasa serious sandwich production line that included mostly young workers, most were pleasant, some were just rude. It was fairlybusy to be fair. I will not be returning to this location. There are others in the immediate area with better customer servicethat smell more clean. Read more