Reviews for Manhattan Bagel in West Caldwell, NJ
Literally had two plain bagels with cream cheese and it was just short of 9 bucks. I heard of inflation but seriously give me... a break. Never go back agsin so much better options in town!!! Read more
Walk in at 140 ask for a sandwich they tell me they?re not cooking anymore food. I ask why they just said we stop cooking at 130... but it doesn?t say that anywhere. What?s the point of being open til 2 if we can?t buy food. Employees were very rude and werealready counting the register just focused on leaving as quick as they can. Read more
Fantastic steak sandwich. Nice staff. A bit expensive for the amount of food. Very measured.
Seriously unlike any other in the chain bagel store experience. Nearly nothing on the bagels while charging a premium price.... There's not enough "steak" on a steak, egg and cheese to feed a child let alone an adult. A smear of cream cheese?? Cold hotcoffee?? Just ridiculous customer service. Read more
Manhattan Bagel is a Caldwell town favorite! I love it, the entire crew is awesome, friendly, quick and efficient. They make... great breakfast and lunch sandwiches/ wraps, to your custom specification. They have the best, freshest bagels. If you arecoffee connoisseur, they have great roasts including their unique vanilla nut (my favorite). Try it, you'll love it! Read more
I love this place! The staff is extremely courteous and they even clean off the grill of bacon grease to make my vegetarian egg... white omelet. Plus the food is amazing, bagels are always fresh! Read more
I had a problem with an order via Door Dash. I called this location by accident and was rudely informed by the woman on the... phone that they didn't have this service here. With a snip in her voice, she told me to have a nice day. Then hung up. Based onthat experience alone, I wouldn't ever go there. Mistake or not, that's not how you handle the situation. But now, you have lostcustomer before I even set foot in your business. Thank you. Read more
Worst location by far. Definitely prefer to go to the roseland one