Reviews for Pietro's Prime in West Chester, PA
The atmosphere of the place was nice. It had the right amount of busy for a Friday. We were glad that were able to get some... great seats at the start of the night. The service was good and our waitress was nice. The seasoned drinks were good for aparty of 2. Called oh snap to match the fall season trends with blood orange gin and ginger beer. As someone who is more of awine person rather than beer, it was tarte but in a good way. The apple cider vinegar and shallot mignonette sauce matched theessence of the oysters. The crab cakes were good. The only problem was our steak which missed a little finesse especially sinceit was well done instead of medium well done. All in all it was a good fall festive experience. Read more
We visited on a Wednesday when the WC TAPS promo of 1/2 price apps was in effect. We made a meal of 2 appetizers, the tuna... tarts and the crab cake, as well as a side Caesar salad, NY strip and potato. The crab cake and side salad was more than enoughfor me as a meal. My companion's steak was excellent, perfectly cooked and very flavorful. We also both really enjoyed the tunaapp. Additionally I had the cocktail of the day which was a refreshing cucumber spritzer. We did not have reservations and couldnot get seats outside. This would be a great special occasion restaurant since it can get pricey as everything is a la carte. Read more
Saturday night dinner hit the spot at Pietro’s Prime in West Chester. The Martinis were perfect (have to be or points removed)... thank you. Andrea our waitress was great. Calamari and shrimp cocktail apps were delicious and my bone in NY Strip was cookedjust the way I asked. The management or possibly owner stopped by to asked about our meal. They actually care! Check it out youwill not be disappointed. Read more
Great wait staff and experience/venue. Great food and great cocktails,. we'll be coming back here more often. Love the broken-up... feeling of the restaurant spread out of what seems like multiple different interconnected buildings. Love the exposed brick andlook. One of the finer dining experiences in the West Chester Borough. Read more
Phenomenal! We arrived at 8:30 pm last night after attending the viewing and service of a dear friend. We were afraid they would... deny us entry as it was quite late. But instead we were welcomed in and quickly seated. First of all our drinks were amazing tosay the least! I really enjoyed the Lavender Lemon martini, as did my significant other as well! I had the crab cakes whichrivaled those of my Uncle, Michelin Star rated Chef Marcel Martin. There were sensational and contained zero fillers. Mysignificant other had the surf and turf and claimed it was one of the best he's ever eaten. We dine at many upscale restaurantsand we both concur that this was one of the finest meals that we have had in a long time! Eating at Pietros was a fine way forus to end what was a very sad and emotional day for us otherwise. Kudos to the staff and the owners of this fine establishment! Read more
We recently had an evening out to celebrate three birthdays with 12 of our closet friends and what a fantastic time it was!! It... was absolutely amazing that everyone's food was cooked to perfection (this rarely ever happens with such a large party), thelibations were flowing, and the service was absolutely stellar! Mark, the owner/manager ensured that our experience was nothingshort of excellent and our server Julia was most accommodating to say the least! Thank you for making our celebration amemorable one! We will definitely be back! Read more
Pietro’s prime was a lot of fun in the sense that the waiter was very engaging/hilarious. The restaurant itself was very busy... and there is only one small bathroom sadly. They had great menu choices so I was really excited! The biggest let down was thewait, we were at the restaurant for at least 3 hrs with a 2 hr wait on the food itself - granted I guess we were a big group andit was Friday. Then when the food finally came and it was kind of a let down too. Everything was very under seasoned. The foodwas not as warm as everyone would have liked almost as if it sat. I ordered the house signature 10 oz ribeye. Cooked perfectlymedium rare with a great sear! Super flavorful with that classic steak bite/texture. My boyfriend ordered the 20oz filet whichwas also cooked perfectly and melted in your mouth. It was so annoying it was not hot enough because it was so good! You haveto dress your plate essentially so I took a photo of my ribeye with all the sides next to it. This is a steak house so it wasnot surprising that salmon was a huge let down. Very under seasoned and cold. The sides come out as “family style” so theyare larger and shareable. The best side was the creamed corn, super creamy and delicious. The steak fries were cold and soggysadly. The smashed potatoes just needed seasoning. Great restaurant overall maybe it was just too busy of a night for thekitchen. May consider coming again. I just wish the standards were just as high as the bill came out to be. Be ready to spendmoney here! Read more
I was visiting my Daughter and Grandchildren. We just happened by. And went in to get a bite to eat. We didn't know that... reservations were usually required. But the staff accommodated us without hesitation. Friendly relaxed atmosphere. Our diningexperience would not have been complete with out our waiter Andrew who was especially good to us. Very attentive to our needs.They all get a double thumbs up and 5 ???? stars all around. Read more