Reviews for Farmington Avenue Pizza House in West Hartford, CT

Their Pizza ???? is delicious, probably the best I ever tasted. Every thing is nice and clean and always the freshest... Ingredients. Read more

This was by far the worst pizza I’ve had in my entire life. The staff were very nice guys but the pizza was built on the worst... dough you can imagine. Owners of you’re listening, you’ve got to change your crust, it didn’t even resemble pizza. Are youusing flour? What the heck is going on back there? You could also rent your restaurant out to a film studio that is filming apost apocalyptic movie. I want you to get better not harm the business. Thanks for lunch guys, it was just good enough so Ididn’t drink the gasoline out of my car. Read more

Worse pizza I have ever tasted! Over priced for horrible quality. Place is out of date & touch. Service was annoying since they... kept asking do you need anything else. Paid 4 slice with 2 drinks & it came out close to $30. Never going back! Read more

We have lived in WH for 3 years and have never tried this restaurant until tonight. We ordered a gyro and a small cheese pizza.... My husband liked his gyro and the pizza was good enough. The only odd thing was I had ordered a gyro with French fries but hadnoticed when I got to the car that there were no fries. My husband went back inside and they told him I hadn’t ordered fries.He said ok no problem. But for how much our meal cost, it appeared they had charged me for fries. On the handwritten ticket itsaid fries (FF) as well. I’m giving 4 stars because I’m pretty sure they charged me but then said they hadn’t. Weirdsituation overall. I’m annoyed too because tipped them. Read more

I have been going here for 45 years. Gus is super nice, always makes a delish pizza, Greek Salad, Steak Grinder and Chicken... Parmigiana Dinner! It's great and nice to support your local small business! I feel like family each time I come in here! Thankyou, Gus, Penny and all staff!! Read more

Stopped in for a small pizza while waiting for a swim meet to end at West Hartford Aquatic center. Pizza was as I remembered,... delicious. My family used to come here in the 80s growing up in West Hartford. I think the recipes haven't changed. I will saythe prices are a bit "West Hartford" but I'm sure his rent is too... Read more

The weird thing is, I don't disagree with some of the negatives on here (I'll specify which), but I still like this place. Greek... style pizza is getting harder to find, but this place makes it and makes it well. We always order pizza and a Greek salad. Thefood is always ready when we get there. The pizza is always hot, and the salad comes loaded with feta and fresh vegetables. Thebiggest issue I've had is with pricing. My order is often two or three dollars more than I'm expecting. On the other hand, Ionce dropped a 5 in the tip jar and the guy working said "hold on" and took 5 off my total!! That tip didn't do much good... Iget that for some people that kind of thing is a deal-breaker. Maybe better you read this than give it a super negative review.For me, the same old guy is always working, making me think it's a family business. It's got a nostalgic old vibe to theinterior. And it makes the kind of pizza I grew up eating and don't find as much any more. On a Friday night when we're cravingpizza and a bit of nostalgia it does the trick. Read more

Food tasted fine - first time ordering here, meatlovers and wings. 3 stars for the following ; Ordered by phone and quoted 25... minutes but I arrived on time to pickup and the pizza wasn't made yet. Masks below noses, no gloves. Meatlovers on the menulisted toppings of ham, bacon, and pepperoni - toppings on the pizza provided was hamburg, pork sausage, and pepperoni. Wingson the menu listed as tossed in Buffalo sauce but condition of the provided wings was unsauced with sauce on the side. Maybe ifyou're regularly ordering knowing what to expect you would be fine as the food was cooked right, but the surprises were not whatI wanted. Read more