Reviews for Reservoir Inn in West Hurley, NY
Reservation at 6pm. Dinner arrived at our table 8pm. Chef was alone and could not handle the amount of covers. Anyone looking... for a sous chef job? Food was delicious. Server was very kind and brought us extra bread. Read more
Been years since i was here. Best chicken cordon bleu i have ever had. Everything was delicious.
It's amazing this place has such staffing problems for the past 2 years. I can't understand how 1 hour to get simple appetizers... in a largely empty place. Told there's only one chef who's also the owner. Being a career chef I can't understand how oneperson is so inept at their craft that they can't even run their own business correctly. It's a shame that after eating thetrashy appetizers , I'm not impressed many restaurants around the area are much better soup was old salty and not French Onion,falafel is a horror show, shrimp satay from the freezer bag. Can't wait to see how these overpriced underwhelming entrees aregoing to be. No prime rib on a Friday Night, really was a staple in the past. Do us all a favor, and hire a chef, who can atleast cook a steak and not use old sour garlic or undercooked Temps very sad. Read more
I haven't eaten here in years, since my grandfather was alive and well enough to bring us out. But for over 2 decades he brought... us here to eat, and I have a core childhood memory of the quarter run Mr. PacMan game that was by the bar. I probably wouldn'tbe able to eat here now due to dietary restrictions, but this place is awesome and I'm glad to see it's still around. Read more
Six of us went there for mother's day, plus my six month old granddaughter for her first dinner out. The staff was outstanding... for being short handed. It was a nice relaxing experience with great food and drink. At the end of our meal I felt trulyblessed to have a great family friendly experience at the Reservoir inn. Read more
The steak is perfect! My wife and I came here for date night and had a great time. The stone work and old timber?s are... beautiful, the service was spot on, great wine selection, and the food is sooo delicious! And when the check came I wassurprised by how reasonable the price was. We?ll be back! Read more
Honestly i give them 7/10. Great atmosphere. Food was great except for the fried calamari which I don't recommend. Rosemary... mussles were delicious as was the ahi tuna and salmon. Wine is good and great price. Minus points for: soft and chewy calamari.Flat 7-up in a shirly temple. When asked for a new drink it was still a bit flat and still charged for both drinks. Service wasok, we got appitizers quick, and salads after, but waited almost a half our in between salad and main course. I would good backa try again. Read more
Absolutely fantastic, our families go to spot for special occasions and my wife's favorite restaurant in general, food is... delicious and good value. Sometimes there is definitely a wait for your food but it's always worth it and the serving staff iswonderful. Read more