Reviews for Secatogue Brewing Company in West Islip, NY
Are you a mid-30s/40s parent of a baby or toddler that likes high quality craft brew? You're out near fire island as well? Well... you have found your calling and it's this brewery. The Kid/Dog/Adult ratio is incredible at Secatogue, beyond what you've everexperienced on Long Island. My 3 kids under 1 yo, 3yo, and 7 yo, had a great time while us two parents had a great time as well.I'm sure they don't advertise themselves as the family-friendly brewery and to be honest the only hit against them is theirnon-family-friendly bathroom signs calling people @ssholes. This place is epic and if you love beer and you have kids, you willlove it too. I had the Captain Cameron and Vibe Shift. Extra props to the crew running the place with incredible craft icecream, which took it up another level on the family scale. Thanks to the manager for keeping it all under control Read more
Came here as a part of their Wednesday night trivia night special which was an absolute blast. The selection of beers changes... periodically, but seems to have a decent focus on IPAs for the most part, but they have other options available if that's notyour jive. I got the Gorilla Cake stout, which was very smooth and delicious with a 10% abv to boot. They also typically have afood truck on standby so food options will vary depending on who's around. The place is a little on the smaller side, but that'sone of the things that I like about it most, it feels more intimate. Facilities are well maintained and staff is friendly. Goodaccess to parking as well with a separate lot right next door. When the weather is nice they also offer outdoor seating. I'mexcited to come back for more, definitely one of the better breweries I've been to on the island! Read more
Absolutely love this place. Some of the best beer I have ever tasted. Their dark beers are excellent (Universal Sound, Sleigh... Queen and Lei'd up are a few of my favorites). They are always friendly in the tasting room and have outdoor seating during thesummer. Can't wait for a Darkest One We Had and an Agave Trigo. Also loved the Cherry Emoji! Hope they brew those again soon. Read more
The beer was awesome!! The food truck on site was absolutely horrible. We ordered a speciality French fries with bacon and... popcorn chicken. Three friends tasted it and all agreed first a rip off for $13 the size of a small fries from burger King andfour tip bits of chicken?? A waste of money. Tasted like nothing more than deep fried. Read more
I love this new spot. Their beers are awesome, almost too awesome since they come and go so quickly and the brewery doesn't have... any mainstay beers yet. The atmosphere is friendly and fun; I like that it is bright unlike a lot of bars. Their food truck isgreat too. My only issue is the lack of parking. Read more
Great facility, tasty beers, and an awesome staff. We held our Long Island Beer and Malt Enthusiasts monthly meeting here and... the membership was very please with the beers and hospitality Read more
Great beers, great people in a relaxed atmosphere. A very nice brewery with a great staff. Growlers to go and food trucks... complete the experience. They definitely specialize in IPAs but other styles are served as well. Go ahead give it a whirl! Read more
This has always been a happening spot. But the beers have improved a bunch since opening