Reviews for Ann & Tony's in West Jefferson, OH
The food was delicious. This is a great dive restaurant with a true mom and pop feel. The service was amazing, but the food is... what really made it! The lasagna was probably the best I've ever had short of my own (not bragging) and the owner with meatballsthat my wife got was delicious. The brownie was so good we practically fought over it. If you are even close to this place...Go, trust me, you won't be disappointed! Read more
This is one of our favorite Italian restaurants... It's close to our daughter's house we don't get a chance to eat there often.... But, it's wonderful when we do! Thank you ???? Read more
As always amazing food (the chicken parm is my favorite) and great atmosphere. Love hearing the live band the last Tuesday of... every month. Read more
Some friends and I visited after a neighbor made a recommendation, claiming they had the best authentic Italian food in the... area. Although my review is pretty neutral, I didn?t hold the ?authentic? claim against them, since it was the neighbor thatmade this claim, not Ann & Tony?s. The restaurant was nice, and the staff courteous. We had reservations and didn?t have towait to be seated. The service was a little slow, but like many restaurants these days, they were understaffed, so it wasn?t fora lack of effort on the server?s part. She was nice and efficient when she was able to see to us, so that aspect was really aplus during our visit. The salad seemed like bagged salad. It was okay, but not special. The house sauce was good. The breadwas fresh, but light and fluffy, not the more dense traditional Italian bread. The herb spread had a nice flavor, and realbutter was provided in little packs. I ordered a sampler platter that included a few Italian staples, so I could see what Iliked. I had penne pasta, spaghetti with meatball, and lasagna (?Tony?s?). The portions were ample. Unfortunately, the sauce forthe pasta was very plain and seemed no better than something straight out of a can. It wasn?t bad, but it lacked flavor and wasuninspiring. The pasta was overcooked and mushy. The lasagna was the best of the trio. I?d order that alone if I visitedagain. All together, the pasta sampler was pretty average. For a small town eatery, this place was fine. I?d eat there again,but wouldn?t travel out of my way to do so. Read more
Love mom and pop?s businesses, this restaurant has amazing food!! Spaghetti and meatballs was yummy!
Great service. Better food. Everything pictured was fantastic. Fairly priced as well.
This is a lovely small-town restaurant with lots of charm and good food. It is decorated in country style and the wait staff are... friendly and helpful. The menu offers a range of options that includes steak and seafood. Prices are reasonable. There are notmany places like this unless you want to travel to Columbus, and deal with crowds, traffic and noise. We will definitely beback. Read more
This was my second time eating here. The first time eating here, the food was good, not great. This time around, the food... reminded me of cafeteria food. Quality has definitely went downhill. The service was great both times. I believe we had thesame server. The atmosphere has been very bland both times I have been. The atmosphere would be better with some music playing.There are speakers but nothing playing. Read more