Reviews for Amici's Pizza in West Lafayette, OH
Way too much cheese. More cheese than crust. Normally it's amazing tonight not so much
Just moved nearby and didn't think I'd find cauliflower crust but they had it! Reasonably priced and honestly it's the best one... I've ever had. Got takeout and it was ready in 15min. Definitely will be back. Read more
We ordered the meat pizza and the everything pizza with Buffalo wings. The meat pizza my husband wouldn't eat. Said it was... gross. But the kids loved it. The everything pizza was excellent! I ordered it with no cheese do to my food allergy. Still wasfantastic. The wings were great! The waitress was attentive and so sweet. It seems to be a local place. Over all I give it a 9out of 10. I only do this because of the cleanliness. The bathroom available is upstairs , this is not a wheel chair friendlyrestaurant. The bathroom was very dirty and had a soap dispenser filled with water I assumed to help create more hand washingliquid. But wouldn't even lather. The toilet as soon as I sat on it the lid fell off and hit the floor. The resting over allcould use a good scrubbing. Read more
Great local resturaunt, they are very supportive of the community and give back often. Pizza is good, only local pizza place for... the village of West Lafayette. Read more
Great to see this place doing so well. It was a huge part of my childhood, when it was Village Pizza, and the new incarnation is... just as good! Glad to see the young people still have a great place to hang, and it's just a great place for the whole family!The service is impeccable, fast and more than efficient! The food is phenomenal! Highly recommend this little piece of history.The new owners and management are doing great things! Read more
Excellent Pizza! The Salads looked great as well! The cauliflower crust pizza is very good as well.
First time trying Amici's, good pizza for a good price! Got an extra cheese pizza and it came with an excellent amount of... cheese. Sauce was a little sweet and that's just not my preference but it was still an okay sauce all in all. Bread was decent. The cheese really sold the pizza for me though, quality taste. Definitely would order again! Read more
First time getting food here and I love it!! All this time passing and I find a gem!!!